Backpack Question

Aldaron

Aldaron

Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2012
Messages
1,487
Okay, I got a new backpack a couple of months ago, and FINALLY got a chance to use it last night up towards Allsop Lake. The pack is the Osprey Atmos 65. It was bought to replace my Kelty Moraine 3600...you know, because I thought it was time to enter the 21st century with my backpack. Actually, that's not true, if it hadn't been for a negative confrontation with the Boy Scout Exit of Coyote Gulch and a busted bottle of 100% Deet a couple of weeks later in The Needles, then I would still be happily carrying my 10+ year old backpack. But, alas, I did need to replace it, and the Atmos had all of the features I was looking for.

But during the hike yesterday, I noticed that my right hip...really, slightly below the hip...was getting sore. It felt like something was pressing into my muscle, but feeling around, it didn't feel like the pack was anywhere near the muscle that hurt and nothing was pressing into me. So I decided that the muscle was just getting sore very quickly. Now that I'm back, the muscle is sore...I don't think it's bruised.

So my question: is it possible that my old Kelty pack just didn't set on my hips correctly, and now this pack is setting correctly, so my muscles are sore from adjusting to the weight distribution?

Or does anyone else have a negative experience with this pack? Does it not set right?

I don't think this is a simple case of just being out of shape from the winter...I don't remember ever feeling this pain in the past.

Anyway, sorry for the long-winded question, but thanks for the help!
 
I would assume that they both sit differently and that you haven't spent enough time with the new pack or gotten it adjusted just right for you yet.. You could also be loading the wight differently in this pack causing it to ride differently as well..
 
Hmm.. I don't know. My first inclination would be that maybe it's not fitted correctly but that's a total shot in the dark. Definitely a possibility that you were just used to your old pack fitting odd and now this one is different. One thing I've noticed is that a lot of people tend to wear their packs way too low on their hips. Just curious, do you know how much weight you were packing? As far as the Atmos hurting, I don't own one but I have several friends that do that have had nothing but great things to say about them. As for me, I've loved every one of my Osprey packs, Aether, Kestrel and Stratos. If I were in the market for a 50L pack, I'd probably get an Atmos...
 
I have an 2012 Atmos 50 and I must wear it higher than my other packs while hiking. The metal frame tapers at the bottoms and if I ride "too low" it works into my hips. If you have a 2012 you should be able to adjust your shoulder straps 1" then toss some weight in there and see if its still hits you sore spot.
 
Hmmm...yeah, I wonder if it's setting too low. It didn't feel like the frame was digging into me, but maybe I was just checking it on flat ground. I guess I need to try playing with it more on the trail next weekend. I thought maybe it was too big for me, but I double-checked my torso measurement, and I'm well into the medium range. I also measured the old pack, and it was actually bigger. I don't know. I'll try fiddling with it some more and give it another couple of trips to see if I can adjust it to me, or if I can adjust to it.
 
I have an older Atmos and have had trouble with the bottom edges of the back board causing hip soreness/pain. I'll probably DIY some type of a pad for it before my next trip. Part of it is weight distribution but I believe part of it is design as well because my other Osprey pack is fine.
 
My hips and shoulders start hurting just looking at my pack, so I can't help except to say that anything you strap to your back and load up is going to take time to get used to. Not very helpful I guess.
 
Well, it just occurred to me that with my old pack my shoulders would hurt at the beginning of the season...but my shoulders aren't hurting after yesterday at all. That suggests that the load is setting differently...which is probably a good thing.
 
I also find that if I cinch the hip straps too much, it cuts off my circulation, or presses a nerve in such a way that my upper leg, very near the front of my hip bone starts hurting. It makes walking uncomfortable. I have figured out how to balance the weight between my shoulders and hip belts in such a way that I don't have to tighten the hip belt to that point.
 
After using the pack again this past weekend, it felt really good. I don't have any shoulder pain like I used to have with my old pack, and this time I didn't have any hip pain. I think it was just a matter of the weight being distributed somewhere else, and my hip muscles needed to adjust. The thing breathes great, and my back doesn't sweat nearly as much as it did it in my old pack.

Bottom line, I think I'm going to be happy.

Now I just have to see if my new solo BearVault will fit in it this weekend as we head up to the Gros Ventre.
 
Yeah, and the place I'm trying to get to is above tree line, so I figured it was time to break down and buy a bear canister.
 
Stepped in a big pile of hot steamy bear dung on a hike yesterday. Not GRIZ, but.....I decided to cut my hike short.
 
I love Osprey. I have an Osprey Raptor 18 for biking. A Talon 22 & Talon 11 for day hikes. A Talon 44 for traveling light & when I want to travel abroad but not check my bags. And an Aether 85 for longer trips when I need to bring a lot of gear.

I tried the Atmos out. I loved the design. But I found that the suspension system, as cool as it is allowing airflow....that it was uncomfortable when heavily loaded. While the Aether seemed like I was carrying nothing...an equally loaded Atmos felt like I was carrying twice as much. I really felt it.

I think that's because of the suspension system, the pack & the load sit farther out from your back which creates more pull and a weighted heavier feel.

When packed light, its great.

I just preferred the way the Aether hugged my back.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
G Escalante area 4-5 night backpack trip suggestions in late September. Loop if possible. Limit technical sections if any. Thanks! Backpacking 6
Tim Valentine Eastern Sierra Backpack 2023 Backpacking 16
T Cloud Peak backpack Trip Planning 0
F Little Death Hollow Backpack Trip Planning 2
F Upper Escalante River Backpack conditions Trip Planning 6
C Grand Gulch Cedar Mesa Utah 11 Day Backpack October 2022 Backpacking 10
Ugly A Washington Backpack and some driving Backpacking 14
BJett Big South Fork National River & Recreation Area Packraft/Backpack Loop (TN) Backpacking 6
Kerrie at Thru We Go Grand Canyon Backpack/Packraft Loop at New Hance Backpacking 11
kwc Osprey Aether 60 Backpack for sale Gear 3
S Mentasta Mountains, Wrangell St. Elias National Park and Preserve- family backpack Backpacking 1
forest dweller The best / ideal conditions/ criteria to backpack with a stranger / allow a stranger to backpack with you... General Discussion 6
J Canyonlands Needles District simple backpack with a close friend April 1-3, 2021 Backpacking 2
J Grand Canyon NP Backpack Pt. 2 Deer Cyn explore-->Esplanade-->Indian Hollow Tr. April 18-23, 2021 Backpacking 10
J Grand Canyon NP Backpack Pt. 1 Thunder River Tr.-->Esplanade-->Tapeats-->Deer. April 18-23, 2021 Backpacking 13
forest dweller Invite update / edit - have off second and third week in August - wanting to backpack in Glacier, Olympic or Yellowstone, hinges on finding companions. Meet Up (Members Only) 37
forest dweller What do you think is the best way to meet other SERIOUS backpackers when you only backpack once or twice a year and... General Discussion 52
Arizona Jones Wet Beaver Creek Arizona, Backpack Trip Backpacking 10
regehr quick Jarbidge backpack Trip Reports 5
NorthwestWanderer Overnight Backpack to Louis Lake, Lake Chelan-Sawtooth Wilderness Backpacking 4
Perry Ideas for Camera and Lens Carry Inside a Backpack Photography 11
regehr south waterpocket fold backpack Trip Planning 27
TrektheWorld Salt Creek or other Utah Backpack Meet Up (Members Only) 2
Ross Permit places available for a Cape Solitude/Comanche Pt Grand Canyon backpack (+Canaan Mountain) Meet Up (Members Only) 0
J Paria Canyon-Vermillion Cliffs Wilderness, UT-AZ Backpack: April 26-29, 2019: Days 2-4 Paria River Backpacking 3
J Paria Canyon-Vermillion Cliffs Wilderness, UT-AZ Backpack: April 26-29, 2019: Day 1 Buckskin Gulch Backpacking 2
Mikjik86 Waterproof backpack bag for packrafting? On The Water 6
George_Washington_Hayduke Clearwater - Bowdie - Fable Valley - Gypsum - Easter Pasture -8 Day Backpack/Packraft Loop Backpacking 36
Janice Hermit Trail to Granite Rapids - backpack in one day? Trip Planning 8
Janice Recommendations for Colorado Backpack? Backpacking 25
G The Maze! 6-day backpack trip Backpacking 5
SKLund 5 day Yellowstone Backpack Trip Planning 12
E Gentle (Flat) Backpack in Utah Trip Planning 1
T K9 hiking adventures & K9 backpack advice. Noobs: Introduce yourself! 1
Rye Jones Backpack Suggestions? Gear 4
pixie1339 Suggestions for carrying ashes in a backpack General Discussion 13
J The Grand Staircase-Escalante NM. Paria-Hackberry 10 day backpack April 23-May 2, 2017 Part 3 Backpacking 4
J "Mazing" Six day backpack in Canyonlands Maze Dist. Pt 2. April 13-15, 2017 Backpacking 8
J "Mazing" Six day backpack in Canyonlands Maze Dist. Pt 1. April 10-12, 2017 Backpacking 0
SKLund Fable Valley Backpack? Trip Planning 5
T Advice Needed for 5 night Backpack route in Southern Utah Trip Planning 2
J A New Classic Death Valley Natl Park Backpack Nov 16-19,2016 Backpacking 5
J Newbie - hoping for some advice on one night backpack in utah Noobs: Introduce yourself! 3
SKLund Cedar Mesa Backpack in October Trip Planning 3
Joey An 8 Day off trail backpack through the Crest of Grand Teton National Park Backpacking 22
Eugene Southern Utah - Suggestions for 3-4 day backpack in October Trip Planning 4
Skiwi Ruby Mountains backpack 06/28 - 06/30 Backpacking 10
Kullaberg63 Seek Outside Unaweep semi custom backpack Gear 3
J Canyonlands Needles Dist.: Crosscanyon Backpack Traverse April 10-15, 2016 Backpacking 1
J Glen Canyon NRA: Reflection, Cottonwood, Llewellyn Canyons Backpack April 25-28,2016 Backpacking 5

Similar threads

Back
Top