Desert or Mountains?

Desert or Mountains?


  • Total voters
    39

Jackson

I like to go outside.
.
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
2,257
I'd probably pick mountains 75% of the time. I love the views, the smell of the pines, the wildlife, and having a bunch of water sources nearly always accessible. I often see the desert as how I get backpacking/camping/hiking in when it's too snowy and cold for a regular mountain trip, but I've come to enjoy it a whole lot. It really helps that the optimal seasons for both, as far as I'm concerned, don't overlap a whole lot.

I'm saying this after several months of not backpacking in the mountains though, so maybe my current views are skewed. Often, by September and October, I'm longing to spend some time in the desert and enjoy its loneliness. So maybe I'm not so sure.

Anyway, that this is even a question really highlights how fortunate many of us are to be frequently faced with a realistic choice between the two.
 

WasatchWill

Ready For More
.
Joined
Jul 23, 2013
Messages
1,501
Ha! Should have figured this was coming. I was going to make this comment on that thread, but I'll put it here instead. I embrace both. I love the change of seasons and the diversity and contrast between the two. Whenever I'm down in some uniquely textured winding and twisting desert canyon or roaming along a rim or ledge overlooking such a canyon and what not, I think to myself..."I love the desert. Maybe I really am a desert rat because there's no place I'd rather be."

Then when I get into a beautiful alpine basin later in the summer, I think to myself again..."There's no place I'd rather be." If I could cut myself in half to be in both places at any one time, I would. But if really forced to choose, in the interest of surviving, I'm at a point now where I'd have to just flip a coin. For now though, I voted desert, only because it's that season now. That vote would be different if it were now summer.
 

Shirt357

Member
.
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
251
I would say this is a tough choice honestly. I think no opportunity to hike should be turned away whether it is desert, mountain or winter/summer. To me its year round fun! Though no way I would be headed to too many desert locations in summer lol. However, mountains will drag me in year round. In some ways I enjoy winter more there...
 

IntrepidXJ

ADVENTR
.
Joined
Jan 17, 2012
Messages
3,298
I'm definitely a desert rat.....which is the reason I moved to the Colorado Plateau in the first place! Don't get me wrong, I definitely enjoy the mountains in the summer (when the desert is too hot anyway), but I spend most of the rest of the year in the desert.
 

SteveR

Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2016
Messages
422
Well....at one time it would have been "Mountains" without even thinking about it. Because skiing. That was before my first desert trip in the early 2000's. Lately however, as winter makes it's approach I often have the urge to extend our annual October desert trip through the winter at least once, just to see how it goes. I have sometimes posed a similar question to myself and others:
"If you had to choose between living somewhere with prime mountain biking but only marginal skiing, or the opposite-what would it be?"
I would pick the location with great MTB for sure.
Realistically though- because I still ski at least 60 days of cross-country and backcountry a season, and the mountains rule in summer- that's where my vote went.
 

Perry

Formerly Cuberant
.
Joined
Aug 8, 2016
Messages
2,028
The mountains are a part of my soul and I would prefer to be there than in the desert. I have always liked to look at the desert when others would find "nothing to see here". Having said that I gained a new found appreciation for the desert when I went to Capitol Reef NP late last spring to do some hiking... and I want to go back for sure!
 

MikeM

Member
.
Joined
Oct 12, 2015
Messages
360
Mountains, no contest.

I say that mostly because I was born in Montana, spent most of my life here. I did spend a few years living in the California desert, but I really wasn't into backpacking or hiking much yet, so never really learned to appreciate it I guess. The few times I did hike while living there always seemed to be in the mountains nearby anyway.
 

Nick

-
.
Joined
Aug 9, 2007
Messages
12,888
Well let me think about this...

Mountains

Colder
More bugs
More likely to die of hypothermia, exposure, moose trampling, bears, etc.
Have to wear more clothes
Harder to walk through (hello, passes!)
Have to carry more stuff to keep warm and protect from bears, etc.
Trees blocking the views too much

Deserts
Warmer
Less bugs
You can practically walk around naked
You don't have to carry much
Not as many things are trying to kill you
Less trees = more views

"Strolling on, it seems to me that the strangeness and wonder of existence are emphasized here, in the desert, by the comparative sparsity of the flora and fauna: life not crowded upon life as in other places but scattered abroad in spareness and simplicity, with a generous gift of space for each herb and bush and tree, each stem of grass, so that the living organism stands out bold and brave and vivid against the lifeless sand and barren rock. The extreme clarity of the desert light is equaled by the extreme individuation of desert life-forms. Love flowers best in openness and freedom.” - Edward Abbey

"Back to the earth, back to who I am and who I am not, back to my kin, the sandstone in my veins." - Katie Lee
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
J More fine and aesthetic desert summits scrambles Dec. 1-3, 2020 Hiking & Camping 2
J Footlose and unfocused in the Mojave and Sonoran Desert Dec. 8-10, 2020 Hiking & Camping 2
J On to towers of the Sonoran Desert with friends; Nov 21-30, 2020 Hiking & Camping 6
J N. Mojave Desert Rambles and Scrambles (start of 40 desert days) Nov. 14-20, 2020 Hiking & Camping 4
S Idaho Centennial Trail to Oregon Desert Trail Backpacking 23
Stephanie B Our Intro to the Red Desert, September 14 - 16, 2020 Hiking & Camping 4
andyjaggy Bikepacking West Desert Trip Planning 16
SteveR Desert Roadtrip 2019 Hiking & Camping 4
TrektheWorld Salt Creek - Needles or other options in the Utah desert Trip Planning 4
Jackson Walking Along a Nice Creek in the Desert Backpacking 28
stevecochranephotography Desert Winter Run Off - Big Dominguez Canyon Hiking & Camping 2
regehr touring bike for the desert? Gear 9
canadug Spring Break in the Mojave Desert Hiking & Camping 4
J Desert mylar General Discussion 14
JDWalters Access to Escalante River/Lake Powell near Cathedral in the Desert Trip Planning 7
Mikjik86 Desert Canyon/Water Shoes? Gear 9
DrNed Ideas For 1 Night Backpacking In Utah Desert? Trip Planning 10
Titans 3 week Arizona road trip: Tucson Desert Rain & Hiking SAGUARO NP Hiking & Camping 1
blueeyes West Desert Bikepacking Everything Else 13
westy Anywhere, Mojave Desert Hiking & Camping 3
Wanderlust073 Winter in the desert Gear 16
TrektheWorld Meetup in the desert Thanksgiving week? Meet Up (Members Only) 1
SteveR Desert Roadtrip 2017 Hiking & Camping 13
Perry West Utah Desert Hiking Opportunities? Trip Planning 4
Perry New to Desert Hiking... Any Advice? General Discussion 8
SteveR Canucks in the desert-an October Utah trip Hiking & Camping 8
BryanG Anza-Borrego Desert Part - 2 Hiking & Camping 0
BryanG Anza-Borrego Desert Part - 1 Hiking & Camping 4
Scott Chandler A Return to Desert: Little Wild Horse Hiking & Camping 7
Vegan.Hiker Desert noobs visit Zion and the North Rim Hiking & Camping 28
Nick Desert Magazine 1963: Lake Powell General Discussion 10
Hurakan Dogs In The Desert. General Discussion 11
Bob Cathedral of the Desert Canyoneering 1
Kullaberg63 Clark Mountain - a remote California desert peak. Hiking & Camping 6
Bob Cathedral of the Desert, Clear Creek - Top Access Resource Discussions 0
hatchcanyon Cathedral in the Desert On The Water 17
Christian A Desert that's as sculptured as the Colorado Plateau General Discussion 2
Nick Cathedral in the Desert On The Water 18
Dave Anza Borrego Desert, October 2013 Off Road 10
Nick Invite New Years Eve in the desert Meet Up (Members Only) 40
gloo The Desert Rat General Discussion 0
Dave Lower South Desert, Capitol Reef Trip Planning 0
Momoegy White Desert, EGYPT "Stars time lapse" Hiking & Camping 13
Dave Cathedral Valley - Middle Desert Wash Trip Planning 11
Nick Who's stoked to get back in the desert?? General Discussion 26
gnwatts Desert Pools Photography 18
Nick Album Spring in the desert Photography 44
uintahiker Camping in the West Desert Hiking & Camping 9
pixie1339 Invite Zion Best Of The Desert Loop March 10th-11th Meet Up (Members Only) 72
Alison Desert Rocks- Moab 2012 General Discussion 0

Similar threads

Don't like ads? Become a BCP Supporting Member and kiss them all goodbye. Click here for more info.

Top