Sam's Mesa Box/NOLS Exit/Twin Corral Loop-Rest of Story

Don't like ads? Become a BCP Supporting Member and kiss them all goodbye. Click here for more info.

Dave John

Soopapoo
Joined
Oct 29, 2017
Messages
4
Pictures first. Then narration below. I'm trying to fill in some gaps left wide open from previous hikers - namely the Coconato/Sys trip and the descriptions by M. R. Kelsey in his guidebook, Canyon Hiking Guide to the Colorado Plateau 6th edition.
This is the first major drop of the Wingate Bypass. Note the cairn at the extreme top of the downclimb.

The second pic below is at Camp 2 above the NOLS Exit of Sam's Mesa Box Canyon. Coconato camped on his night two below this site.

IMG_0317[1].JPG
IMG_0309[1].JPG


Burr Point; Sam’s Mesa Box Canyon; NOLS Exit; Twin Corral Box Canyon Loop: The Rest of the Story – Utah.

David Johnson and Ian Bartling

October 15-18, 2017

I was intrigued first by this route described by Kelsey in his book Non-Technical Canyon Hiking Guide to the Colorado Plateau 6th ed. It was a loop to begin with, not an out-and-back, plus it was in an area of low-frequency hiking. This description interested me. I also read all of the online sources including the one where a couple bailed after seeing what Kelsey calls “steep downclimbs” within the first two miles of the descent from Burr Point. But most interesting was Coconato and Sys’s video and map account of a March 2015 trip covering what Ian and I duplicated, in part. I say “in part” because we failed to trace their second humungous day which included an attempt to ascend what I’m calling the “Kelsey Exit” up the main fork of Sam’s Mesa Box Canyon and marked in green on their topo map. Coconato and Sys report that they “came within a few feet” of exiting via this route. The steep walls prevented them any kind of safe exit. Instead, they retreated and made a huge descent down some serious steep slickrock to the bed of Sam’s Mesa Box and then ascended another 1500 feet via what I am naming the “NOLS Exit” shown above the “Camp Night 2” icon on Coconato’s excellent map. The NOLS Exit is the route Ian and I took. For Coconato and Sys to not only try to exit the Kelsey Exit and then successfully negotiate the NOLS Exit in the same day is remarkable. These two guys are animals.

However, this NOLS Exit is way more involved than Coconato leads the non-technical hiker to believe. Furthermore, Kelsey doesn’t even mention this route; he’s never even done it, I think. It tasks both the physical and mental prowess of even a seasoned desert-backcountry hiker. We found the boulder field noted by Coconato and previously explained to him by a single party member of 12 or so NOLS students and leaders. However, the boulder problem is only about a third of the total exit-route description. Above the boulder field a gully leads into a red and black-streaked wall that without a pack would demand a rock climbing move of about 5.6. This wall blocked any further safe travel up the main gully. We looked right for other options. The Coconato map shows an extreme right-hand traverse along a ledge and then up to a clump of pines and into another gully that finally tops out onto the Navajo Sandstone (5800 feet) characterized by rounded and spacious slickrock humps and mounds. The top-out is extraordinary scenery because of its wildness and solitude. Plus it’s a great high camp. However, you had better have hauled up the exit six liters of water each to cook dinner and stay hydrated the next morning. The next good water in October doesn’t spring up until reaching the big pools in the Upper South Fork of Twin Corral Box Canyon.

So are you starting to understand my main criticism about these previous route descriptions? Kelsey, Coconato and Sys all purposely leave out hugely important details, or, fail to mention them at all. Coconato leaves out any narrative of the tricky right-hand traverse above the boulder field on the NOLS Exit. Why?

In addition, Kelsey in his published and much acclaimed guidebook only vaguely describes another huge obstacle with the understated phrase, “routefind down in” (116). Coconato and Sys don’t even mention this one. This barrier Kelsey calls the “Bypass Wingate Dryfall” (117) and it’s located on the Coconato map a quarter of a mile above where the 2015 trip map shows they had cut up the main fork of Twin Corral Box for an eight-mile afternoon "jaunt." Why are these descriptions so scant or non-existent?

The Wingate Bypass initially blew us away. I toyed with thoughts of turning around, to be serious with you. The Wingate Bypass is a formidable downclimb that many rock climbers would choose to rappel. When descending the canyon, the bypass is found at the terminus of a ledge that skirts the left side of a large dryfall in the South Fork. I rate the “downclimb” as 5.5. Ian and I are seasoned backcountry hikers and our 35-foot rope was totally essential; without it, we would not have made it down this 45-foot “bypass.” We are both rock climbers, and we both had sticky rubber shoes that worked beautifully on the clean rock. At first, we dropped our packs at the top cairn and butt-slid down to the first ledge, no problem. Then Ian made what he called a “Spiderman Traverse” to the right. This traverse is the crux. All of these upper moves must be made intentionally and without any mistakes. The drop is for all intents and purposes a very exposed, nearly vertical, deadly rock face. I make this conclusion, after experience on Denali, Mount Rainier, Half Dome, Forbidden Peak, Mount Hood, Grand Canyon, Canyonlands and several other serious desert and mountain ventures. Be careful.

Ian completed the traverse and then moved left over another less-scary ledge to the second major ledge where we would soon lower our packs to. Ian skillfully moved right again over a third ledge onto easier ground and the creek bed. From the creek bed there was still another twelve foot drop that provided absolutely no foot holds after the first four feet. You would have to jump the remaining eight feet or do what I did: rig up a rope loop that hung suspended in the middle of this final eight feet. I would have liked to have videoed this short descent and my keen foot placement into the loop. I comfortably lowered my other foot onto the sloping mud at the base of the rock and pulled my foot out of the loop. I untied the knot in the loop and pulled the rope loose from the mega-ton boulder that rested at the top of the small pour-off. Pretty cool.

Ian descended the whole route solo to begin with and then climbed back up to me. I scooted over the Spiderman Traverse and over to the second ledge. Ian lowered me the two packs from the top with our rope. The packs got pretty beat up while being scraped on the rocks. I stayed with the packs while Ian descended clear to the lowermost creek bed, below the twelve-foot pour-off. The packs were lowered a second time from the second ledge to Ian 40 feet below. Finally, I descended the route, made my nifty foot loop, and we were down safely looking to make camp below the main fork of Twin Corral. This under described, briefly mentioned Wingate Bypass took Ian and me one hour to maneuver. It was easily the most difficult and intimidating section of the entire Sam’s Mesa/Twin Corral Loop.

I know it’s manly, adventurous, cool, mysterious and maybe “proper etiquette” to under describe the difficulties routes throw at climbers and hikers. However, the two descriptions of this loop were the most scant I have ever read. Would I have done the route had I known what I know now? Yes. Would I have been less intimidated by the these two huge problems had I known more about them? Yes.

IN my opinion, Kelsey and Coconato are trying to imitate the route descriptions of "hard men" like Fred Beckey. Fred described rock climbing routes in the Cascades in much the same way. “Move carefully to the right,” meant that if you were not able to make a 5.10 move on a traverse, you would not be finishing this route. I guess Fred meant to add some surprise to the route with these understated descriptions.

Listen, boys, Fred is dead. Be realistic and add the details that will fully inform the backcountry climber and hiker what lies ahead. Don’t be cool, be real.

Other omitted details important to hikers wanting to complete the Sam’s Mesa Box; NOLS Exit; Twin Corral Box Loop (listed in order of importance – most to least):

1) The coordinates to the first serious descent where a rope lowering is advised: N38 10.482; W 110 27.287.

Here (just above the Kayenta Plateau and only ¾ mile from the trailhead) there are two easy downclimbs and then the third, more serious, down climb of 20 feet. We definitely lowered our packs on this third down. I started facing outward and then faced in for the bottom eight feet.

2) The scariest and narrowest ledge traverse underneath the Great Alcove is toward the end and on the north side. But I would agree with Coconato that it looks from afar way more scary than it turns out to be.

3) Water in October was a concern. The water with white salt deposits on the creek bank is, duh, salty. Get water in the larger pools even though they are filled with dead leaves and have deer and bobcat tracks next to them. This water tasted less salty. A pump filter works well.

4) We precisely took Kelsey’s route into the upper South Fork of Twin Corral Box Canyon. We traveled with a GPS and two 7.5 minute topo maps (Burr Point and Robbers Roost Flats). Coconato took a more straightforward gully into the South Fork of Twin Corral which, from his pictures with his route description, looks doable. We chose to go with Kelsey at this point in the trip. The descent here included a bypass of two large pour-offs with the first mile. These required a pack lowering of 15 feet and a doable and easy ledge traverse to a boulder field that fed into the main creek bed. The initial lowering was marked by two cairns.

5) Crossing The Dirty Devil River is not a big deal.



Below is the second drop of the Wingate Bypass on the South Fork of Twin Corral Box. I had to rig a foot loop here.
IMG_0319[1].JPG
 

Attachments

Last edited:

Don't like ads? Become a BCP Supporting Member and kiss them all goodbye. Click here for more info.

Wanderlust073

Member
.
Joined
Oct 30, 2016
Messages
612
Not sure about the Kelsey book (vague and poorly formatted from start to end imo), but Coconato doesn't claim to be writing guides and there's a lot of people in general that don't like spelling out every step in an attempt to keep visitation down *shrug*
 

Dave John

Soopapoo
Joined
Oct 29, 2017
Messages
4
Not sure about the Kelsey book (vague and poorly formatted from start to end imo), but Coconato doesn't claim to be writing guides and there's a lot of people in general that don't like spelling out every step in an attempt to keep visitation down *shrug*
I think Coconato does claim to be a guide-man. He has 25 trips youtubed.
 

Wanderlust073

Member
.
Joined
Oct 30, 2016
Messages
612
I think Coconato does claim to be a guide-man. He has 25 trips youtubed.
Many of which start with "this is not meant to be a guide".
 

Brendan S

Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2016
Messages
323
Great loop! Agreed with Wanderlust, and why I usually just don't even say where I was on trip reports these days. There's plenty of info out there already. Proper way to use Kelsey: find the little dotted lines that indicate there's a way in or out and make up your own loop. Takes a little work but it's a lot less frustrating that trying to follow his directions. He's notorious for getting people in trouble so you kinda just gotta look at it as a barebones amount of possible beta and be prepared. Get some Steve Allen if you want honest and detailed descriptions (though again I find it a lot more frustrating and confining trying to follow an exact route).

As for the above loop, I've done the both the whole loop (out the head of SMB) and a day loop down the "NOLS" exit and out the end of SMB (both solo, and I'm not a climber though I'd say I'm a pretty seasoned Utah backpacker) and I guess I don't really see the big issue? It was 2011 when I did the whole loop so maybe I'm not remembering it well enough, but I feel like it was a pretty typical CO Plateau canyon hike that's off the beaten path. Some pack lowering and scramblin should be expected, and trying to figure out how the hell to get in or out of a canyon is a part of what makes it great. It's funny because I don't recall having any issue with the things featured above, including the exit at the head of SMB, but I had a hell of a time finding the route down through the Navajo to get into TCB. That said, I think it does highlight the need to be prepared and sufficiently experienced (sounds like you were) for the less published routes.

And finally (unrelated), seeing the letters N-O-L-S with southern Utah canyons sends shivers down my spine...sure wish they'd stop taking those hugeass groups in those canyons. It's insanity.
 

Kullaberg63

Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2014
Messages
510
I agree, very unique character. I've emailed a bit with him. Would love sit down face to face.

His books are a mess, but hidden in there are the gems needed to inspire adventures. The info/page quotient is thru the roof.
 

Nick

Spiral out.
.
Joined
Aug 9, 2007
Messages
12,701
Welcome to BCP! Sounds like a wild trip and a ton of fun! I'm personally glad that so many details were missing and I hope it stays that way.

I think Coconato does claim to be a guide-man. He has 25 trips youtubed.
I haven't been following Joey lately but I've never taken his videos/reports as any kind of guide or route description. Filming and sharing a trip report does not necessarily make someone a guide. It seems the line between a guidebook style route description and a trip report that gives some helpful bits of info are easily blurred.
 

Bob

Trailmaster
Joined
Mar 3, 2013
Messages
2,289
Imitating.. .don't think so. The books are guide books, not a hold your hand dissertation. Every trip report is to show something of the country, videos are a enhancement, not hold your hand either. If you need the specific turn here, climb down here you shouldn't be out there.

Get real .......
 

Don't like ads? Become a BCP Supporting Member and kiss them all goodbye. Click here for more info.

slc_dan

Desert Rat-Weekend Warrior
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
1,657
Thanks for posting your experience!

I too enjoy the route finding that goes along with vague write-ups. I've been Kelsey'd myself. It led to an adventure that I look back on fondly, but didn't quite enjoy at the time (type II fun).

The thing I think I've enjoyed most from Kelsey, and Allen (far superior in terms of specifics), is not really following anything after a while. I look at maps, look for some kind of weird fold or crinkle, and see where it takes me. Some of my best trips haven't worked out, and I've had to make a plan b, c, or even d.

Glad you were able to enjoy the loop, looks killer! Love Love Love the Dirty. Mostly because it's so difficult to find a way around.



And finally (unrelated), seeing the letters N-O-L-S with southern Utah canyons sends shivers down my spine...sure wish they'd stop taking those hugeass groups in those canyons. It's insanity.
Oof I agree. There has been a few places in the Roost I've come along that looks like there were very large groups there, and weren't in the best shape after I've read NOLS on the registers.

I agree, very unique character. I've emailed a bit with him. Would love sit down face to face.

His books are a mess, but hidden in there are the gems needed to inspire adventures. The info/page quotient is thru the roof.
I got to meet him once while there was a showing of "Gorging" at our local "Brewvies." He was chatting up a pretty young thing while I stood stupidly with a guidebook I'd grabbed off of a table. I was hoping to purchase said guide book. After I finally caught his attention after staring at him for far too long, it turns out the books weren't for sale, but for a raffle at the end of the movie. Definitely felt stupid.

I only hope I can be in as good of shape, and still get out like a madman in my 70's and 80's.
 

Nick

Spiral out.
.
Joined
Aug 9, 2007
Messages
12,701
Looks like @Dave John mentioned us in his article in the Montana Standard.

Top 10 treks: An outdoorsman's list of adventures near and afar

http://mtstandard.com/news/local/top-treks-an-outdoorsman-s-list-of-adventures-near-and/article_614c5021-9d52-5273-9218-8d860b7ef6ef.html

The relevant piece is below. Click the link above to read the whole article.

1. Sam’s Mesa/Twin Corral Backpack Loop — Hanksville, Utah.Yeah, I know, it’s not a Montana trip, but ain’t it great to be an American! This slick-rock, off-trail backpacking trip of 25 miles is easily one of my top all-time most beautiful — and one of my top toughest, too. It contained some of the most remote and lonesome desert landscape I have ever seen. Two-hundred foot rock pinnacles, a desert bighorn sheep, and silence so still that all I could hear was the ringing in my ears. Staring down 40- to 50-foot rock cliffs and knowing I had to down-climb them or turn around was the reason for my high-difficulty rating. I posted some comments concerning the difficulty on a website called backcountrypost.com. My comments prompted several seasoned veterans to chime in only minutes after posting. One guy (Thunderballs, I think) said that the hike wasn’t “that big a deal.” Oh well, maybe it’s my age creeping up on me!
Thanks for the mention, Dave! BTW, who's Thunderballs??
 

Dave John

Soopapoo
Joined
Oct 29, 2017
Messages
4
Looks like @Dave John mentioned us in his article in the Montana Standard.

Top 10 treks: An outdoorsman's list of adventures near and afar

http://mtstandard.com/news/local/top-treks-an-outdoorsman-s-list-of-adventures-near-and/article_614c5021-9d52-5273-9218-8d860b7ef6ef.html

The relevant piece is below. Click the link above to read the whole article.



Thanks for the mention, Dave! BTW, who's Thunderballs??
Looks like Brendan was who I was referring to. My mistake.
 

Don't like ads? Become a BCP Supporting Member and kiss them all goodbye. Click here for more info.

Similar threads

Don't like ads? Become a BCP Supporting Member and kiss them all goodbye. Click here for more info.

Top