Lower Horseshoe Canyon

Udink

Still right here.
Joined
Jan 17, 2012
Messages
1,710
"Surely there must be more rock art in Horseshoe Canyon outside of the Canyonlands National Park unit, right?" I've often had that thought, and I finally took the opportunity to test it out. The canyon spans 25 air miles from its head near Hans Flats to the mouth at the Green River, but only about five miles of that, in the middle part of the canyon, is a part of the detached national park unit that contains the famous Great Gallery and other incredible Barrier Canyon style rock art. I figured the best chance for finding additional rock art would be near the mouth, where an abandoned meander of the Green River forms the horseshoe shape for which the canyon is named. I recruited Chris to accompany me on the trip and we left town on Friday afternoon. A little while after turning north onto the Spur road we encountered a man walking toward us on the dirt road. I customarily stop when I see people walking on remote roads just to make sure they're not in need of any assistance, but before I rolled to a stop I saw the NPS logo on the guy's shirt. It was clear that he was just a Park Service employee out for an evening walk, but I chatted with him for a bit anyway. He asked what we were up to and I told him we were going to camp at the end of the Spur road and hike down the Angel Trail in the morning. I was surprised, then, when he asked if I'd checked in with Kathryn at the ranger station and whether we had a camping permit. "Nope," I said, "we'll be on BLM land so none of that is necessary." I'm not sure whether he was just flexin' or genuinely didn't know anything about the area and its regulations. He abruptly ended the conversation with an, "Okay then, you guys have a good time." Continuing north, we saw some nice views of the La Sals and the Abajos in the spotty sunshine, though as we neared the end of the Spur road the skies grew dark. A couple of miles shy of the end of the road we hiked to the rim of Horseshoe Canyon to do some scouting for the following day's hike. Just as we reached the end of the road the sun peeked out very briefly, lighting everything up pinkish-orange before setting. I had planned on setting up a tent but the sky cleared before bed time and I ended up sleeping on a tarp on the ground.


La Sal Mountains
68AlR3IuFannxcRBfoRDCMiy2zlOOPktU0he1eVMdUe7_B8DCYITreKCLKvE-jnSPPc26astI48IQA=s640


Abajo Mountains
kYHwwAKS9vdOx25dgAX7dWxD2YI0HyIHNC3bEor2ZzckLtO11KWHjL7Ako7rUwivE2RF1KzT-nWggw=s640


Dark skies, with flat terrain belying the canyon country ahead
_bZVSVsIL1snnMxdC6WHO1KAfD1OhUFy3s31dvyEC8rcaGOd7jP5pJOvk4i74vzHKW46m8WbX_5PbQ=s640


Lower Horseshoe Canyon from the rim
ITW6u1mpIh-T3E_qQbPcfdc6zMb0VDfEnyUFoLEwLLq6tpMatIqNiuHIa4xvB2ddvU1_IUuYb6ehdw=s640


Two-track road across the Spur
mzjanZN7fzvnEeidVtoUVAuMDmWzMG-U03g0-BNr8npcAPKA0Ge_OdDv-UqPGz75SIJpx17GQhNTKA=s640


Shadows rising on the canyon walls above the Green River
Sl-btGFZZgsSDO8XbU_q3P8tCpUkWEK3YyvfgJZsgC5jtkKrMpxM8BnqGguO5Ku7wMWX3tPn_QRnig=s640


Book Cliffs
2S4zJj11c9k2BDnGymjhljUz4LhS07oSLYhbw_Wf3peXbC9zHiwBiQxRQ2A4NiHCceaVzOXGt2JeJw=s640


Henry Mountains
kGkj9JFKy1fYX_eINHEK4HzENMdnaDt-CW0N0TghVeXsAstpCm_e_4emQSTbJKHebUCiiNJYu02mLw=s640


Camp fire and cell service!
RjHO3kxEWuVDELanMBwBgMJucYWGW7fLO_1meTLTKBT9e3TmnmA5vymI4dsNPXhIchaI1PnEJesJzQ=s640



The sun woke us up on Saturday morning and we had a leisurely breakfast before loading the Jeep and driving a few miles up the road. Another relatively flat walk through the brush led us to the rim of Horseshoe Canyon and the top of the Angel Trail. Lithic flakes were abundant along the rim and we each even found a worked point. The trail was a piece of work! A tremendous amount of construction was done to make stairs and ramps over the many ledges to make them passable to livestock. In at least two locations there were signs of the sandstone being blasted off to make the route wide enough. After descending 1,000 feet we were in the bottom of the canyon. Water was flowing through the sandy wash, and we followed it upstream. The previous evening's scouting trip to the rim convinced me that there would be more potential for rock art in the sandstone walls upstream rather than the high talus slopes downstream.


Breakfast and bed
1o6aM1WZ6axZYAEAjwbF2oOgL55JK3EgdOHE99mFEgd45b3Ns6ooWynag89ulSl7yj1_HhU3WbQCEQ=s640


Road sign
l5SqU2TZnQRbnuY9M9D7GOibAgwpGDTe3q8Tjy1pjipahZpqrlGed7tOhtTjMHFjumbVvTPpuytFFw=s640


Faint dozer track
1Ow1gj-GLD0PDE0rzOK48ovHP4qi3iPHVlNJ4J6yzRg0wBGsX4tBsaNm5DMXF_T2KnjgYB-se3qmUA=s640


Worked flint
bMDXSF04Nmv674svS_m2ZBkDwFQMiKUe_LNQL3lc4EWw9oFwGqGD8l66H7vATJAbNEx4wLOkdddIBQ=s640


Horseshoe Canyon
JPhAQKzcDBT88t0q2A6nbtywOctX20HFu5Y3Wu6MmBxfHdblVSXQ5LtJiFE6wR9CpOx96jlKm5Zg9A=s640


Lower Horseshoe Canyon
vYoz3cs_9YPX5s30yQI8JKUv6TCiOsree1A-19FnEhNn9DZg0xVXWsIbtMOtvwCH1o7KL8uTpQUAOQ=s640


Impressive rock stacking on the trail
6JFrNjKH3sbDHlIJjGWienhykIe0lzecNISE220SYyYj7hwDgCKyLXfhn-8g2H04iolY7c4jEYGyAA=s640


Chris descending the stacked rocks
CeOr_HSmjMim8cydKBOjzmQXVZdB7_2MuO8bCowWiyJYxjhi6OlwSLehIbqblb1JWseP0zmFxE4AvQ=s640


Descending the Angel Trail
AnUmP8K7BqYLgbJDfVu-6XaU-Mt-kJI0WA_AKd9ewXNdS-EWONXpuI3xZaXnEHTgCobZv22wNgYWJQ=s640


Part of a long, stacked stone ramp
2QpRl1szYEUWpaoI-4KkBxP6wMp8f0Iqo9J70F9y09xb8pKNUlnNbjxFfqtNETYfXwWZ6np76Q0irA=s640


Across some ledges
RZXNlyBSIru1CidWu0CR_cKEopqiCdEhn0pYBtsuvyvqRKrWVwmVIY6Jrx-1d5_VpGAJHerqYnkm3Q=s640


Sandstone fractured by blasting
C4TpOuIrSgpko3AoduSVRx8BJYEEDXIx32t2hwMcgRnxzIWg9Xr8-L6iBlwpSe2js2JGw9BNn0dePw=s640


View up the Angel Trail
94yBN-vi4B6NawUYibva3Hz-3fZFBRBGn_Q24vWjLQUg_6a91P_oOi7BZhj_YZ3A-2MDPSOErxXZCA=s640


Water in Horseshoe Canyon
8oo3rf2TYFKFyyGVLFcFCHDYRbx8Dpp915HAYlL8TBnxFgd4vk3EkBcinwjpbO_7HsxxahFCmjMMNg=s640


Hiking upstream
W4ah5DPjNKlAqSpeqp-_dRATm_k6eoPJiVqUclz8c-R4_vbs2kzRhXJVvsqh6H8PGwBW-6eCIjuQ_w=s640



Cactus flowers were prevalent but there were a few other wildflowers in bloom. At first the hiking was easy, across firm, damp sand and with few plants in the way. Farther upstream the going got tough. The watercourse narrowed and became choked with cottonwoods, willows, and tall grasses, and in places there was quicksand that threatened to swallow us if we didn't move quickly. I sunk once to my ankles for several steps before I could escape to firmer ground. After a lunch break we thrashed through the jungle some more. I climbed out for a higher vantage point and couldn't see any relief from the thick undergrowth ahead, so we returned back down the canyon and checked out the section downstream from the Angel Trail.


Showy Milkweed (Asclepias speciosa)
z34iFoKx5zaNA_-vZT_7FxBBDpUetohSG56O_gdYxspbOr0tQpkPJIP8kAZzXaDkx6hjVcSb7c5WCg=s640


Prickly Pear Cactus (Opuntia polyacantha)
ggYHHjWSAvuHtbcS0RjmWZ5XBFlKjnA6NAGnKns1yHPh4M23q5d2GPR2JVPFCUlS0nFRoPI3o3IgBg=s640


Prickly Pear Cactus (Opuntia polyacantha)
nTu9ogvkUMIFkDMuyS5S4peT0hFcHBsJE4fzSecgldmaf5hrpJdGIJEcYvM5bjbcsuAOIRPJ0TZ_AA=s640


Side canyon which may be passable all the way to the rim
dlo6Jsz8tz4NqSXiB8jXYD9ErWV8-FYKJhCkdZp94boE6TIw85e088zKwFZougeq2YnDdqHGWluOSw=s640


Quicksand!
ZZak0gsM_tNZLShcKbJ2l4dqT5nn1Cs7u8tHyqjwjeUKjOf9T3W6tUIm0MIOHQyLiFVG0kH8dnNt3Q=s640


Thick growth in the canyon bottom
xrf0JPceczlXQ4st1BISkZ4QbIJTp-zvN58fCJrAQnsFN5NsmjzxjGlnlLd9096stAXgJ5zAcVmfYA=s640


Bushwhacking up the watercourse
VgC4oKUwrMmd5vcXbvaSybCYhv9KmCtH7GlOaNmbLp01TOhtDONwr3m6mW1-gLPStv56IRKKUz-KHA=s640


View from above the floodplain
NFFBfP2mHFpZmFEyUku6LrxL8opbJjADECcuQt5xqhzmD9XRFRaNihHI-DYRogp2-fWGnpCcHpjAwg=s640


Five-foot-wide fossilized mud cracks
3u4gdVuTZJxZWujbtNzJlN6OI0NQl8PG8PR1-k7_umHSNoshHF1Xk2-JyoXGcuCIGf0MXogOcTDeiA=s640


Toad
v6UwTt-RQXWMs4Ypw1dqGRTI2fbI1bjO4a9X_pho3FciwAYz1o3xmFQCxrQntz0DyVAqS_gNIoGvPw=s640



The stream had receded and the watercourse at the bottom of the trail was now dry. It was a mile or so of easy walking before we climbed up into the abandoned meander of the Green. Low rock walls had been built to hold livestock inside the rincon. We didn't go far into the meander because there were great views of much of the surrounding terrain. I spent a lot of time scouring the surrounding cliffs and boulders with binoculars but didn't see squat. The many large boulders nearby were devoid of even cowboy writings.


Cottonwood growing on the edge
4TJjvS6mhWW2ker3nL9hO-OrAFMf0Q_WRJSUdMJmkq_5QrcNazFEtu-nyqCFQJNwGZpjyfLXI1CV1g=s640


Lower Horseshoe from the downstream end of the abandoned meander
o5tcquVy1BaY854MwpXM0BHcMGun8Eqitw7bUGlAF3V1drOX_1EUYwZrPMjZbkdBQX34uatBvVmLvw=s640


Old firewood stack under an overhanging boulder
bzTNXNiY-lgB_cWZcxY5hGG5t3qWiIKCHvBVbeUWjwPVq5MtnMTmUBXfDGAH_mdpgm7UsGEtc4s1wg=s640


Stacked rock walls to keep sheep in the meander
rkAc6vqnO5pGtUQtzh5RKiUBup9keRU54J4CcOOM1JrHjYua3TCwkXnPbtet6ZCW8ldLd4yL1INZOw=s640


Checkin' out some boulders
TnrnMJM3OK_aqvxLUvt3AmN_bkkQ_KJNrI02FUvDD3vSlymk2ZvfOxEfVNw2_yg3LIgD0HJOmERiWw=s640


Lookin' squatchy
B5nTn6UpD7ppecTNYUB_g-ao0idkMyHCofneZBxL1AIEn45mCJ99ctKoLHwCJaOgBMz9v7iY5RvVnw=s640



It was easy to make the call to head out of the canyon. I was surprised that we'd seen virtually no signs of human presence other than the constructed stock trail. It had been a long day already, but the 1,000' climb up the Angel Trail still lie ahead. I just took it easy and rested often and made it up without much trouble. I finished the last of my water (out of four liters total) at the top of the trail, though I'd been conserving it up until that point. At the top of the trail we found a scattering of old cans, a bucket, a broken wooden box, and a shovel handle--must've been where the cowboys camped. Chris and I returned to the end of the Spur road and camped another night there, seeing another nice sunset and turning in a little earlier than usual.


View while climbing back up the Angel Trail
Rx5FMDsihdOumcu6Ksl2LPKtc0gZO9Ch5aEpXi75Cb-XkppRrCWyAbR4y3vJBj5-Wxf_aCxcuU76yQ=s640


Rusty bucket
R4c4lzrOeE3ilkpU6vTyNkayPy86meFMcvg6jXFXyywpmd7lvXGd7ZxR5UZa38VGr1vbz-FqHOCadQ=s640


Refuse from two different cultures
VoWjyZ3wbBP9iIJkF78EChEYsmFYS1_mDBwuJsB3khvJXopVJmaTa93K-Di_JdQzMnynSrwVZZfsLw=s640


Across the flats toward the Jeep
q9o4Fg-1SlmjsRc0gPvFuggXJsXxsPRlqOepBCIiCVQhjRnp2DrWTvRRNNlWd3OZA_yx7DwT8CVC2g=s640


Back at the same camp spot for the same sunset
N6zaaEygayBzkj5ODep2aJEXk6BFKeMlj6tTpVtHb67JhIW5-dud3JOV4NZLxVZm4OF1vg25bviT4g=s640


Starry night at camp
M0MyNT3qBKbMJ86V9Iz6zMgn3V4AO-2AKdgMkR37wFPTItoK1y2lG7Jf3vSqYvRhC7Tsh1aEQyhEmQ=s640



The plan for Sunday was to simply head home, but with a few stops along the way. The first such stop was at the old Tidwell Ranch. The road to the ranch from the west, which crosses Horseshoe Canyon, was financed by the Phillips Oil Company in the late 1920s. The company had a large drilling operation on the east side of the canyon but never struck any oil. The Tidwell family took over the area and ranched there until the mid-1940s, utilizing the buildings and materials left behind by the oil company. Before reaching the ranch, Chris and I visited a corral made from the separated strands of thick steel cable. At the ranch itself was a scattering of interesting old junk. An enormous wooden wheel--part of the drilling rig--was the first thing we encountered there. Elsewhere were parts of old vehicles, huge timbers, and a collapsed cabin and nearby stove. We spent over an hour wandering and examining all the things left behind.


A bug that was on my sleeping bag
9rK96X5KqXzyzIiqlm8BmoB5HS-bwJg2ef4tgk2rryXjP-1Hp3y-acwPsXKg9i_ApZr5apcY7T4F1w=s640


Corral near Tidwell Ranch
syGcu4pcfIEeBnQZXWes1qc2ZMNMr68NycgDuDEsa3Rwt_mnKcnHVLIqaDKShtLSgEGKyCczAykE1Q=s640


Separated cable strands used for the corral
SqCSzmJEeYLE3u8VvAfaPahEzXg8nm7BFtnIo5kqkJhVi502SkUcPDx0SNsgpbSKJKhnC2uOWLrhQg=s640


Leather strap used for a gate hinge
wMzIGh-M6kF2eZBnZxdCN2tMYIvEKhYJUvQ8AqzxBzY9MdmfcauChKAXeLGQbmo9VnP5YKoW7nAu-w=s640


Drill rig at Tidwell Ranch
gGH9FhQ7ZSUg3nGj-e4CwsQ9XLUy5LgtEWO0GK0p2Cs5Pt9KdDXhemxPElbXfHPSkwHqIO0Yq6FaTA=s640


Old car door
NXurXA3FJUlSJN_FX2hkXEkUtsZ8Y-Zl-B_H0g2QJ7ZCMcatMn1fA7_c8pfQko6OxtfZaAdU_iA36g=s640


Head gasket
wAdlsVecAjS_I8y1J529DBR8WxxWHTHDpMC9I5fUZEjc-Pw_dZ3WsZeVoB5sKwyCU1i2EbpqwdfFpQ=s640


Bottom of a water tank
6e-DMSVmzNAIpyoeK79T4pZbxv4GQGqd1F8iPj8vOBi625AdFUtDcN0vI9Urv1zPwMmfswCIOZP9TA=s640


Water tank detail
V_SRdhqiWYxHLZvzM48wWUdvkN8noB_v68gbBnFtopX430TbndQAeHD8sT5iUJCTz2zKf4xrkQoUxg=s640


Parts of an old vehicle
APhnDQzm4hdstSR_d2P4zpfdBzmrXPOrugTar8YMUEQ87IItaw6YnVbOaqrL3dI7-Eo32vzib_71LA=s640


Truck frame and parts
cf9kZLBkTUGzSRVFm7EcmzDEyM1a480cx8G3wURaI7_c7dgcAoV0YG-5wahOlQjJH9y3vblKUIHUbw=s640


Collapsed cabin
KuNi9Fnyqev9SKjbSaSyujePOOzFW2gk-kzW2x2hzr5dvGpCILcmZ5oovaQFuX_kzq7pY0yEbZ8Ndw=s640


Unusual metal bottle
sNVLyami6nvN0fgwfrv4QZkiZDvlfnJ8ZUNAM5k4-i-uqo6ibF_UWyaGV-iNBVBshpfdqXXv541cuQ=s640


Stove
UZtCf7-jDRX71cYQD3NPXnh6Voo20ZSCXGGUc5DF41bF-skYO8YjQitPjarxBHQw2nxMLwgwWLmwBg=s640



Continuing a couple miles down this side road, we entered Canyonlands National Park and drove to the end of vehicular travel. A cattle guard and chain block access, though I find it humorous that the chain is secured with a padlock on one side and a carabiner on the other. We peered briefly into Horseshoe Canyon, seeing a few hikers and one man walking his horse up the steep road on the opposite side of the canyon. I put the Jeep in 4-low for the rough climb back out from the edge of Horseshoe Canyon. The exhaust had gotten quite hot from the higher-RPM, lower-speed driving, and I started to smell what I would describe as "toasted wood." Driving on rarely-used and overgrown roads had packed a lot of brush and grass between the transfer case crossmember and the body of the Jeep, pressing it tightly against the exhaust pipe and front driveshaft. I stopped and removed the worst of it, and ended up having to remove more after I returned home.


Entering Canyonlands
Tt20TvsdirFdIIQlL9bGbr_jCyuRatfhHy2rvIs9HS6UuI8EjJdWErcQCPa5oyr6O81slBrxHFOawg=s640


Cattle guard and chain across the road
CobY3a6t6c4okhJVoCw0LEGTZTfhrQ6ib643nofmGGv08MzADlHfuJgkvvI1rbthrbimbYoi81jcSA=s640


One side of the chain is locked
omJSXdjhGGeaGmnMB9Oyo60KCJxP-AwJHSqtcs9zmT7V9MTmbkEvcoR8JI8q6w1XYHWfgPnOP0lRiQ=s640


The other is held with a carabiner
SWSkrG4JTsruFtK0bna-I2nA0npIrgfyt_id6Igo_Z5Hi3ZynT1vD3_XhISf6_Afn782YAzReCTjew=s640


Road "impassible"
fNMe_RPMC1wIopnqaoZO9jROGQwjyZnzdmDRuDsUvai3Uv4ovu3j4cL34k9TBYd-lt8RWQYlYmuBpw=s640


Old road on the east side of Horseshoe Canyon
hSRZpGscE-j2MCPAilyFFg-cPGwtJMOcUcU9hTk5h4YfErEIpqk_PDbHXYYig279xhj3x-KbgffX_w=s640


Horseshoe Canyon
CFZpTh88RYx_EaBAjAHYJgFALQPDzGr9iNgKH1g1QMoS2J7hwwlohooLbxkBnGyAcDXn2WFHy1asoA=s640


Man walking his horse
SzDIqHOvDvwvwxFuZZOrA9Lv00C1Drwr32rMP7BDJGxzDY9YvYuCPKG2D-P5kWBS3XrQ8CV1ZWXy5g=s640



One final stop on the way home was at a place the cowboys called Vantage Point, shown as "SPUR 6,267'" on the USGS topo map. It certainly is a good vantage point, with views of the La Sals and Abajos in the distance, and closer is the Green River, Buttes of the Cross, and Cleopatra's Chair.


Vandalized "Spur 1953" survey marker
-kiRBQBsxTuJxCuiNwxnUg56u6j2_p2J3s01fso6Yv4cXfW-iY_fPDaubnryaBVqvlJxIze9dUKP9g=s640


La Sals above Buttes of the Cross
DW6ZpD6DTLBDiGdpb8srtRxGFiYKCbJcMldo_9eWCZS1xhulx7FXrh5DYboWBkyfvAiKFIpBbCQxyQ=s640


Cleopatra's Chair and the Abajos
CoaGs86WuTH8GHSn6Y8kYNe2TGCQd722ra_3jiChlO8YCVPtl-tOPWVAGuhWq_QiHA54gZKzC7bJKQ=s640


The Green River above Millard Canyon
9W_TvX-eZg8soLfI3JyhMre2fic7kmbIgjTWmxAYm31pLldzCepClHyQMZlec890Qw696AaTIxeSAQ=s640



While the search for rock art was a bust, I still had a good time. I don't think my explorations along the Spur are over yet.


Photo Gallery: Lower Horseshoe Canyon
GPS Track and Photo Waypoints:
[ Google Earth KMZ ] [ Gmap4 Satellite ] [ Gmap4 Topo ]
 
Back
Top