Big Agnes vs...a Tarptent?

I loved my old quarter dome. It bit the dust after 8 years and hundreds of nights car camping. At that price, I may just have to pick up another one.

The old version had vertical walls, but the new one looks like they slant in quite a bit.
 
As I said, I bought the Copper Spur 2. I got a chance to use it last weekend. I like it. Not super light but lighter than my last tent. But, I'm not sure I'm a fan of the doors. When they are unzipped I prefer them up and out of the way like on the REI Quarter Dome (pictured below along with my Copper Spur 2 and a Copper Spur 1).

14248946316_ce665cdef8_b.jpg

14248826046_e373c2a66b_b.jpg
 
I am torn between the new REI Quarter Dome 1 and the TT notch or strataSpire1. (leaning toward the notch simple because of weight and price)

Can anyone give feed back on the notch or the new REI QD1?
 
I am torn between the new REI Quarter Dome 1 and the TT notch or strataSpire1. (leaning toward the notch simple because of weight and price)

Can anyone give feed back on the notch or the new REI QD1?

How large are you? The notch is a great shelter but if you're on the bigger side you'll want to look at the SS1. Also, depending on how wide your sleeping pad is it may or may not fit in the notch, it is a very narrow shelter inside. Vestibules are plenty large and because of it's small profile it does well in the wind. I ordered mine with extra guy line attachment points and in very bad weather you can also loop lines through the vents at the top around the poles.

I originally ordered with the mesh inner but sent it back in exchange for the solid inner which should help cut down on fine dust. At times I find myself wishing I had a hare more wiggle room in the notch but I do enjoy the small footprint and it's light weight.
 
I am 6 feet and ~185 lbs. The REI QD 1 is still pretty light at just over 2 lbs. (at least for my current standards) for me that seems pretty good. I am still not able to transition to just a trap, so having the livable mesh is a must for me right now.

With that, I am about 99% sure I will order the REI QD 1 tomorrow for an upcoming trip this month. Good think about REI is even if I use it I can still get a full refund.
 
Sounds like a good plan. Do you hike with trekking poles?
 
Sounds like a good plan. Do you hike with trekking poles?

I don't mind using them but I can't find mine right now. That is one reason I do like the notch, weight savings. However they do offer a 4 oz pole set.

The more I think on it the more I like the price savings over the weight savings, at least for right now.
 
If the dimensions of the notch are scaring you off, take a look at the TT Rainbow. It's a single wall, so be advised of that, but the floor area and headroom are fairly amazing for a shelter that is just a tick north of 2lbs. I'm 6'2 and I can sit up and change clothes inside without any trouble at all.

No trekking poles required either.
 
As a small size (mostly solo) female thru hiker, weight is absolutely a consideration. I've had a squall2 (mr Shares doesn't make them any more) and I've camped with it in the middle of the storm over the treeline many a time, with strong winds and sleet. The only times I got water in was when the back catenary pole broke off and I had to fix it, for the time being, with whatever thing could bw found at the apothecary dash fishing store dash bar in a small town in the Scottish highlands (a strange fishing pole of sorts, which I sawed off, bent and stuck into the tents pole, duck-tapping the broken pole around it). Because the pole was crooked, the shape of the tent was altered and water began to pool every freaking raining night (which was every night, of course) near the back edge, creating a bubble that was leaking in if I didn't empty it every half and hour. Unfortunately, that was the second day of a two- month series of thru hikes in Scotland, Norway and the Appalachians, all very wet places, and the bubble ended up stretching the material which has a tendency to "pool up" a bit now and then when I get caught in heavy rains, despite having replaced the makeshift pole and treated the tarp to waterproofing and sealing. And while sometimes I've regreted not haven gotten a freestanding tent, such as when using the State Park facilities in Canada (awful piles of gravel, no real soil to bury the stakes in and expensive as s....) and NZ's Tongariro Northern Crossing (lava lava lava and more lava and Ah yes! did I say lava?), most times I have managed just fine by using 4 ultralight extra stakes I carry perpendicular to the ones I'm burying horizontally, securing them with rocks, or tying the whole flight with stakes around trunks or big rocks. When there had not been trunks or big rocks around I did what I could burying thee horizontal stakes under a pile of loose material, taking some benadril and sleeping so heavily that I dont really care if the tent is half falling over me.
All in all, saving 1.5 pounds or even half a pound, in exchange for the few times when having a freestanding tent would had been preferable, has been more than worth it. The Squall 2 holds up just fine to the elements and I'm very, very happy with it. Now its time to change it, because all zippers were replaced two years ago by non antitrust zippers while in Asia and the old zippers which could not be removed, got ruined and rusty with the ocean breeze, which I might not have cleaned all that well, and the rust got the new zippers to stick together. But im getting another Tarptent, not doubts. Ten years for a tent I've subjected to quite a bit of use and harsh conditions (I guess a good 700-to 800 overnights over a period of ten years? ) it's pretty impressive. It is maybe not the best for city boys who need space and comfort (and don't treat zippers with care) but I still have to find a lightweight that beats it. ... Companion can carry it's own.
 
Last edited:
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
kimbur96 Tarptent Double Rainbow or Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL2? Gear 2
Jackson Big Agnes Tent Durability Gear 11
Bob Big Agnes coupon Gear 1
B Upgrading Big Agnes tent question Gear 10
SKLund Big Agnes Bag Gear 6
John Goering Big Agnes Cooper Spur UL3 Gear 1
Dustin Gent Big Agnes Shield 2 tent - 1st impression Gear 15
katuah Big Agnes demo tent sale Gear 9
steve Gear Review Big Agnes Bitter Springs UL2 Gear Reviews 9
E FS: Big Agnes Copper Spur UL2 with footprint Gear 0
steve Gear Review Big Agnes Scout UL2 Plus Gear Reviews 16
Dave Big Agnes Grouse Mountain Gear 1
Tyler Gear Review Big Agnes Copper Spur UL 2 backpacking tent Gear Reviews 1
Deadeye008 Big Agnes Copper Spur UL4 40% OFF Gear 0
Deadeye008 Gear Review Big Agnes Insulated Air Core Pad - Long/Wide Gear Reviews 4
Deadeye008 Gear Review Big Agnes Sand Mountain Insulated Pad - Mummy - Long Gear Reviews 0
scatman Rockskipper's Big Adventure Backpacking 8
wabenho Big Pine Lakes – John Muir Wilderness Backpacking 6
J Hopewell Big Woods Southeast PA Trails, Jan 1, 2023 Hiking & Camping 0
wsp_scott Big South Fork Bikepacking Backpacking 1
SteveR Big Spring-Elephant Canyon dayhike. With free bonus vacation pix! Hiking & Camping 13
T How big are the Mirror Lake campgrounds in the Porkies? Trip Planning 6
scatman Big Willow Canyon - June 11, 2022 Hiking & Camping 33
BJett Big South Fork National River & Recreation Area Packraft/Backpack Loop (TN) Backpacking 6
Rockskipper Big Day - Please participate, esp. Scatman! General Discussion 9
LarryBoy SLC: Terrace Hills Drive to Big Mountain Peak Trip Planning 16
CodyL Winds- Big water slide Trip Planning 3
Outdoor_Fool A week in the Big Belly Backpacking 20
WasatchWill WRHR: Day 1 - Big Sandy to Cirque of the Towers Backpacking 19
regehr Lower Horseshoe Canyon and Big Spring Trip Planning 7
wsp_scott Honey Creek (Big South Fork) Backpacking 9
J Death Valley Natl. Pk: Funeral Pk, Slit Canyon, and Big Dune. Dec 21-22, 2020 Hiking & Camping 1
wsp_scott Big South Fork Views Backpacking 14
Gunnahafta Green River <> Big Sandy WIND RIVER RANGE Trip Planning 1
norwegianxplorer Big SEKI loop, Sequoia Kings Canyon Backpacking 1
J Pahranagat Country: Big, open, room to roam Nov.9-10, 2019 Hiking & Camping 0
Tim Valentine Big Pine Creek Eastern Sierra Backpacking 10
NorthwestWanderer My Yearly big timelapse video 2019 General Discussion 10
pstm13 A Family Trip in the Winds: Big Sandy and the Cirque Backpacking 11
misSOULa Montana's Bitterroot Mountains: Big Creek Lakes and Ranger Point Backpacking 2
stevecochranephotography Desert Winter Run Off - Big Dominguez Canyon Hiking & Camping 2
NorthwestWanderer Big Four Ice Caves Hiking & Camping 1
toddrparr Easy family backpacking in Big Thicket Preserve, Texas Trip Planning 0
Scott Chandler Starting Out 2019 in Big Sur Hiking & Camping 10
Born to Hike Windriver 36 mile loop: Skull Lake, Washakie Pass, South Fork Lakes, Lizard Head Trail, The Cirque, Big Sandy Lake Backpacking 6
Mike Jones Big Sur or Zion Next Week? Trip Planning 20
Perry Posting Panoramas - File Too Big Questions, Suggestions & Support 4
Tim Valentine Biking Big Sur Everything Else 6
wsp_scott Packrafting the Big South Fork (KY) On The Water 7
Seamus NYC weekend tripper, occasional big treks! Noobs: Introduce yourself! 2

Similar threads

Back
Top