Salt Creek road appeal

IntrepidXJ

ADVENTR
Joined
Jan 17, 2012
Messages
3,349
I'm sure most here won't agree with me, but this is one area I had always wanted to take my Jeep, but I missed out. So I personally would like to see it opened up again...though with a vehicle limit like there currently is to drive to Peekaboo.

If it ever opened up again, I'd be there the next weekend with my Jeep...
 

IntrepidXJ

ADVENTR
Joined
Jan 17, 2012
Messages
3,349
From your article:

"SUWA and other allied environmental groups believe it's an effort to shoe-horn roads into areas that would otherwise qualify for special protection."

See, I see it the other way...SUWA is trying to get roads closed so that they can protect lands that wouldn't otherwise qualify for special protection...

I enjoy spending time in wilderness areas, but I don't necessarily agree with closing existing routes to create wilderness areas...

As usual, I feel the solution lies somewhere in the middle with a compromise....but I don't see that happening.
 

Dave

Broadcaster, formerly "ashergrey"
.
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
1,722
Being that this is something I covered from an objective point of view, I will refrain from stating my personal opinion on the matter. Thanks for responding though... it really is a fascinating debate. Crazy how one act of congress a century and a half ago still haunts us.
 

Nick

-
.
Joined
Aug 9, 2007
Messages
12,921
I'm actually not far from the same opinion, Randy. While I'm typically an advocate of wilderness, the whole 'Protect Greater Canyonlands' campaign has given me pause. I like the fact there are roads accessing much of that area so that we can get through all the wide, open desert and start hiking. But I'm glad that Salt Creek is closed and I hope areas like it will be vehicle-free. I feel that riparian zones like that are just too sensitive and aren't very difficult to travel on foot because of the available water. When I hiked it, I actually had a really hard time imagining a road going through it. Seems like it would be a beast to keep passable with all the water and quicksand. But like you said, the solution probable does lie somewhere in the middle.
 

Dan

Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2012
Messages
454
randy - you are becoming a bad ass backpacker. you'll be there soon enough, and then be grateful there is no jeepers... :)

of course, i'm half-kidding. complicated situation for sure.
 

HomerJ

Member
Joined
Jan 19, 2012
Messages
1,199
I'm not sure I'd stick the words 'bad ass' in there...I've only been on 3 trips so far... :)
You're already ahead of 95% of the world! :twothumbs:
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Laura V. Four Days in Salt Creek Canyon, April 2021 Backpacking 20
Laura V. Bears in Salt Creek Canyon, Canyonlands Trip Planning 76
P Salt Creek water Backpacking 2
P West fork of Salt Creek? Trip Planning 4
TrektheWorld Salt Creek or other Utah Backpack Meet Up (Members Only) 2
TrektheWorld Salt Creek - Needles or other options in the Utah desert Trip Planning 4
P Salt creek in Canyonlands Trip Planning 13
T Salt Creek Trip Planning 10
dhertbag Salt Creek Canyon Info Trip Planning 2
M Water in Canyonlands Salt Creek early April? Trip Planning 11
Smaugxxx Salt Creek & Bear Box Gear 0
C salt creek canyon feedback Trip Planning 10
Curt Another Salt Creek Canyon Report Backpacking 12
steve Video: Salt Creek Canyon - Memorial Day 2015 Backpacking 2
steve Invite Salt Creek Backpacking Trip May 22-26 Meet Up (Members Only) 4
ogdendude Upper Salt Creek Canyon, again Backpacking 5
Mullet Help with salt creek planning Trip Planning 13
Nick Salt Creek, Canyonlands Backpacking 54
LoriB Salt Creek...AGAIN!!! Trip Planning 1
IntrepidXJ Salt Creek Canyon Backpacking 25
Daryl Yarbrough Salt Creek, Lost Canyon and Chesler Loop Trip Planning 3
JackBurns Salt Creek Aug 2013 Hiking & Camping 8
NateGeesaman Salt Creek May 2013 Backpacking 26
LoriB Salt Creek, Utah Backpacking 5
LoriB Salt Creek Trip Planning 9
Yvonne Salt Creek canyon June 2012 Backpacking 2
pstm13 Upper Salt Creek Backpacking 16
slc_dan Lower Salt Creek/Paul Bunyan's Potty Backpacking 11
slc_dan Salt Creek/Angel Arch March 15-17 Trip Planning 5
pstm13 Upper Salt Creek Canyonlands Trip Planning 3
IntrepidXJ Salt Creek Exploring & The Drive Home Hiking & Camping 3
Nick Salt Creek Bears General Discussion 3
Yvonne Salt Creek Canyon June 2012 Trip Planning 4
R Salt Creek - All American Man Trip Planning 28
regehr funky salt formations near GSL State Park Trip Planning 1
Perry 5.7 mag Earthquake in Salt Lake City Area - Check in Here to Let Us Know You're Okay General Discussion 44
LarryBoy Salt Lake County Lowest to Highest - Or Not Backpacking 15
flynne New From the Salt Lake Valley Noobs: Introduce yourself! 6
Coomba Ogden/Salt Lake area General Discussion 3
gnwatts NPR 1A show in Salt Lake General Discussion 0
Nick Invite BCP BBQ in Salt Lake area this weekend! Meet Up (Members Only) 61
Nick Monument Rally in Salt Lake this Saturday General Discussion 2
George_Washington_Hayduke Hello from Salt Lake City Noobs: Introduce yourself! 1
someguy Rob Bishop to speak with Salt Lake Tribune about Public Lands General Discussion 0
Joey Invite Beer Night in Salt Lake City, Friday December 11th. Meet Up (Members Only) 44
hatchcanyon Salt Wash Road Off Road 0
Bridgette Hi from a Salt Laker Noobs: Introduce yourself! 5
Illuminations2k Hello from Salt Lake City! Noobs: Introduce yourself! 3
B Backpack from Salt Lake City to Midway Trip Planning 5
Jackson Another Salt Laker Noobs: Introduce yourself! 6

Similar threads

Don't like ads? Become a BCP Supporting Member and kiss them all goodbye. Click here for more info.

Top