Hiker Killed by Grizzly Bear in Yellowstone

Since we're on the subject of bear attacks, do any of you have any knowledge of the shelf life of Counter Assault? We purchased 2 cans for a 2012 North Cascades backpacking trip, and have carried them with us on every trip into bear country. We've had them out a few times, but never had to squeeze the trigger. So we've now had them going on 3 years. Anyone know how long that stuff is good for?
 
Since we're on the subject of bear attacks, do any of you have any knowledge of the shelf life of Counter Assault? We purchased 2 cans for a 2012 North Cascades backpacking trip, and have carried them with us on every trip into bear country. We've had them out a few times, but never had to squeeze the trigger. So we've now had them going on 3 years. Anyone know how long that stuff is good for?
There should be an expiration date on it.
There is on ours, but I'm not sure of the brand we have.
Cheers
IRG
 
http://www.counterassault.com/faq.htm

12. What is the shelf life of bear pepper spray?

Counter Assault products have a four-year recommended replacement date because ALL aerosols lose propellant over time. This four-year replacement date means that it will shoot to maximum distance the first four years, and will still spray a considerable distance after that date. For example, Counter Assault Bear Deterrent, when new, sprays 30 to 32 feet whereas many other bear deterrents only spray from 15 feet to 20 feet when freshly manufactured. Though the potency of the pepper does not diminish, all aerosol canister seals will weaken over time, allowing the propellant to escape.
 
The park intends to euthanize the sow and her cubs once they determine they were indeed responsible. What do you guys think of that? I'm inclined to believe that we take risks traveling in the wilderness and a bear like this with no known history of human aggression shouldn't be killed. At least not without knowing more about how and why it occurred. But on the other hand, if there was compelling evidence that killing and then feeding on a human makes it extremely likely to happen again, maybe I could understand. I don't know. I'm curious to hear other's thoughts.

I saw this petition roll across my Facebook feed a few minutes ago. 53k+ signatures of people saying don't kill them.
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/814/...src=LG_fb&campaign=DontKillYellowstoneGrizzly
 
The park intends to euthanize the sow and her cubs once they determine they were indeed responsible. What do you guys think of that? I'm inclined to believe that we take risks traveling in the wilderness and a bear like this with no known history of human aggression shouldn't be killed. At least not without knowing more about how and why it occurred. But on the other hand, if there was compelling evidence that killing and then feeding on a human makes it extremely likely to happen again, maybe I could understand. I don't know. I'm curious to hear other's thoughts.

I saw this petition roll across my Facebook feed a few minutes ago. 53k+ signatures of people saying don't kill them.
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/814/...src=LG_fb&campaign=DontKillYellowstoneGrizzly

I agree. Let the bear live!
 
I'm inclined to believe that we take risks traveling in the wilderness and a bear like this with no known history of human aggression shouldn't be killed.

I agree with that, 100%. Except for the no known history of human aggression part. What kind of history of human aggression do you need? She just killed and ate some poor fawker. She's a man eater. Sounds like a pretty serious history of human aggression, to me.

They say... Humans are downright tasty. Long pork, was the euphemism the last of the cannibals used. The other white meat. Sweet and tender, so all the descriptions go. In the literature, it's not hard to find examples of bears going back for more, after that first taste, of the forbidden fruit. We're soft and slow and full of good fat and calorically dense. And tasty. For an animal that burns fat for energy - unlike most of humanity who've fallen into the carb trap, why wouldn't a nursing sow bear easily capable of stalking, killing and eating us, go back for more? My reading of the literature, says she is way more likely to, than a bear that hasn't tasted the forbidden fruit. I'm sure that will be disbelieved and discarded as nonsense, here. I trust Art to ferret out and read the tea leaves on it, if he wishes, and will abandon the subject entirely now, myself.

I'm all for letting people take their chances out there. Everywhere. In all contexts. Totally in favor of way less rescue and overall concern for human safety. Let idiots (or the simply unlucky), die out at the Wave, rather than further burden everyone with regulations and access restriction which serves only to save the lives of the unprepared. Let 'em just die. I'm fine with that. Apply that concept universally. I'm down.

Bear country? Same deal. I'm fine with letting the bears rule as they please. No repercussion for eating people. Provided, we humans are legally allowed to care for ourselves. I end up as predator turds? Sounds good to me. But, do allow me freedom to fully participate in the event. In which case, take it as sadly, and I won't begrudge the thought, but, I like MY chances.

But that's not reality, or ever going to be reality. The world is moving, at an ever accelerating pace, in the opposite direction. If gov't is going to make rules and restrict our behavior, "for our own good" and the good of the animals, then gov't killing of the killers is just part and parcel of it. I don't see trying to have it both ways as very reasonable. Kill the bear and move on... Else let people get eaten, or not, according to their own conscience, ability and luck. But also let them fully participate in their own fate, without repercussion. But, like I said, that's not reality.

None of which, touches on the real issue here. Which are the financial aspects. Money is the ultimate driver of all policy decision anymore. In all areas of gov't. Finances dictate that man eaters be destroyed. None of our thoughts or concerns will be consulted, except as elaborate diversion. Money best served by destruction of killer bear. End of story.

- DAA
 
I think the bears should live. At the most, they should take them to a less visited area to appease the people who want them killed. It seems appeasing them is the only reason they're really euthanizing the bears anyway.
 
Except for the no known history of human aggression part. What kind of history of human aggression do you need? She just killed and ate some poor fawker.

I worded that poorly. I should have specified no previous history.

My reading of the literature, says she is way more likely to, than a bear that hasn't tasted the forbidden fruit.

See, that's why I asked. I want to hear what others have read or heard as to whether they would go back for more. So thank you, I'd love to hear more if you are so inclined. Obviously it makes sense, it's just not something I have any direct knowledge of.
 
Remember, if those bears aren't destroyed and they injure/kill someone else, the NPS will most likely be sued.

I had forgotten that. It really is all about the Benjamins when you get down to it.
 
I seem to remember the statistics showing that a bear that has predated on humans is much more likely to be a repeat offender. Someone over at the Yellowstone Hiking FB page said that in 2011 a bear that had killed a hiker was just relocated and killed another person a month later. I don't remember that incident and I have not yet looked up the statistics I mentioned. When I do I will cite them.
 
I seem to remember the statistics showing that a bear that has predated on humans is much more likely to be a repeat offender. Someone over at the Yellowstone Hiking FB page said that in 2011 a bear that had killed a hiker was just relocated and killed another person a month later. I don't remember that incident and I have not yet looked up the statistics I mentioned. When I do I will cite them.
The bear in 2011 was a sow with 2 cubs of the year. They did not relocate her that I'm aware of, they just let her be. She then later was at the scene of the dead body of the second incident along the Mary Mountain Trail. She and her cubs where definitely eating him. But from reading that report, it sounded like a few other bears were eating on his body too. If you want a good, long read, that will get you nowhere and really confuse you about the incident, do a search on the NPS Yellowstone website in the news feeds for 2011. Actually, I think I have it saved in my email somewhere. I will try to find it and send it to you. I think you will find it interesting. Hugh and I are mentioned in there.

I'm yet to have anyone give me an explanation for that 2nd attack. The victim was attacked from behind while taking a snack break. His body was there for a few days before they found it. Interestingly, all of the bears in the area overlooked the ham sandwhich lying on the ground from his snack bag. which was still there when they found him. They did kill that sow after the second incident.
 
Last edited:
Also, on that sow from 2011, there was a poster on the backpacker and ynet websites who sprayed a sow and cub off trail in Hayden Valley, about a week before the first death. The sow charged out of a tree strand, and he saw one cub behind her. I've always speculated that it was the same sow.
 
I personally only use Counter Assault. There are a few other brands that are good, I'm just more trusting of Counter Assault.

Counter Assault Bear Deterrent, when new, sprays 30 to 32 feet whereas many other bear deterrents only spray from 15 feet to 20 feet when freshly manufactured
I do think they are stretching the truth here. I test fire every new can I purchase, and I've never seen them shoot 30 feet. Maybe in an enclosed or wind blocked area.
 
There are 2 things I'm particular curious about with this incident:
1. What time of day did this take place.
2. Was he trail running or jogging.
 
Also, on that sow from 2011, there was a poster on the backpacker and ynet websites who sprayed a sow and cub off trail in Hayden Valley, about a week before the first death. The sow charged out of a tree strand, and he saw one cub behind her. I've always speculated that it was the same sow.
Did the spray work in repelling/demotivating her?
 
There are 2 things I'm particular curious about with this incident:
1. What time of day did this take place.
2. Was he trail running or jogging.
Neither piece of information is available AFAIK. From the public or private info. It is not even certain what day it occured on.
 
I personally only use Counter Assault. There are a few other brands that are good, I'm just more trusting of Counter Assault.


I do think they are stretching the truth here. I test fire every new can I purchase, and I've never seen them shoot 30 feet. Maybe in an enclosed or wind blocked area.
I concur although I do see ~20+ normally.
 
I had a situation on July 4th where I did everything right (according to books and NPS), and still had an uncomfortable encounter with a bear.

Just curious, what was your encounter?

As far as @Nick's question, I'm of the thinking that they should be spared, without question, from a Wilderness perspective. But then again, it's not a place I frequent; so I do wonder if my opinion would be different if I was a regular visitor to that Park, or more specifically, that exact area. It's easy to form an opinion from my distant armchair. So at the same time I can see why the locals would be spooked over the incident and the concern over a repeat. But I still say let the bear, and (arguably more importantly), the cubs, live.
 
Last edited:
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
F Group Leaves Injured Hiker Behind General Discussion 3
Rockskipper 'Bear cam' viewers save stranded hiker in Alaska General Discussion 5
canadug Hiker death in Zion National park :( Hiking & Camping 32
balzaccom Hiker history Backpacking 0
GramaNana Hello from Utah - future GWT hiker Noobs: Introduce yourself! 11
zionsky Hiker Dies from Fall at Angels Landing General Discussion 1
zionsky Rainier hiker back from the dead General Discussion 2
Rockskipper Hiker seriously injured by rock at Fisher Towers General Discussion 12
Parma PCT Hiker Trying to Lose 200 lbs on the Trail! General Discussion 7
N FL hiker who travels to Teton Wilderness area frequently. Noobs: Introduce yourself! 3
Perry Hiker Dies in the Wave of Appearent Heat-related Conditions General Discussion 12
Perry Missing hiker in Uintas - Ray Humpherys General Discussion 104
Perry Injured Utah Hiker Rescued Near Kings Peak General Discussion 9
Perry Grizzlies follow hiker - Holy Cow! General Discussion 14
regehr hiker injured and rescued in Little Cottonwood General Discussion 3
WasatchWill Runner's Toe (or Hiker's Toe) General Discussion 10
Deepak YAH. Yet Another Hiker Noobs: Introduce yourself! 1
Mr. Me Another (but Awesomer) Hiker/Photographer Noobs: Introduce yourself! 1
ogg Court ruling, hiker must pay SAR bill General Discussion 12
balzaccom How did the hiker cross the stream? General Discussion 5
Vegan.Hiker Drones to be used for hiker resupply General Discussion 8
Nick Missing Hiker on Kings Peak General Discussion 3
regehr Hiker death in White Pine, Little Cottonwood General Discussion 0
Vegan.Hiker East coast hiker visiting Utah Trip Planning 28
Bill Gear Review Clik Elite Hiker Gear Reviews 9
Yellowstone 1 Gear Review Katadyn Hiker Pro Filter Gear Reviews 3
Ted California couple killed in Yosemite National Park rockslide identified by park officials General Discussion 0
forest dweller Grizzly Bear Kills Backcountry Guide Near Yellowstone, Investigators shot and killed the bear after it charged. General Discussion 13
Nick Wolf killed near Beaver, UT General Discussion 3
ROKTAXI 5 hikers killed.... Colorado General Discussion 2
TheMountainRabbit Report: Grizzly 399 has emerged from the den — with one cub General Discussion 2
scatman Grizzly Lake - September 7, 2022 Backpacking 31
kwc A Few More Photos from Scatman’s Grizzly Lake trip … Backpacking 3
P Scatman's Grizzly Lake hike, 2022 Backpacking 28
scatman Grizzly Lake - Yellowstone National Park - September - 2022 Meet Up (Members Only) 149
napatony13 Trinity Alps-Grizzly Peak Trail Hiking & Camping 0
LarryBoy IGBC Prepares for Grizzly Return to Bitterroots General Discussion 17
W "Cooking clothes" in grizzly country General Discussion 10
K 38 Years Ago Today ... Close Grizzly Bear Encounter in Wyoming's Teton Wild. Everything Else 2
T Grizzly bears in Wind River Mountains Noobs: Introduce yourself! 12
tropicalwanderer What to do: Grizzly in camp at night General Discussion 22
WasatchWill Wyoming Grizzly Range Tracker and DMA General Discussion 11
scatman Grizzly Encounter - Telemetry Podcast General Discussion 0
Rockskipper First grizzly bear sighting of 2019 reported in Yellowstone NP General Discussion 12
Artemus Grizzly Bear Expansion Map General Discussion 23
WasatchWill Incredible grizzly attack survival story General Discussion 7
Bob Grizzly..... General Discussion 4
Dave Grizzly encounter in Glacier Backpacking 20
Joey Trip Videos: Grand Teton's Paintbrush Divide, Grizzly Bear Lake, Avalanche Canyon, Snowdrift Lake Backpacking 14
Joey 4 Night trip in the Tetons, Grizzly Bear Lake, Paintbrush Divide, Littles Peak Backpacking 18

Similar threads

Back
Top