Grand Staircase grazing plan

We are talking about beautiful natural areas, and the question is essentially one of distribution, namely, what is a fair way to distribute access to or use of beautiful land. It is one thing to support the rights of ranchers to use this land as long as they do so responsibly and sustainably, and while you could argue against this kind of use I think that represents a bit of an extreme position. Most people on here appear to be of the view that ranchers need to remember that this land is a public resource and as such it needs to be treated responsibly. It is not their private property to do whatever they fancy.

Bundy indeed did Ranchers a huge disservice. These people depend on the use of federal public lands; "big government" is not their enemy.
 
There is one basic problem with grazing in the desert. It isn't sustainable for the ecosystem. Take one look at all the scars from overgrazing throughout the southwest and its an easy conclusion to arrive at. Ranchers have been there a long time but 15 foot deep creeck beds weren't, not until they overgrazed the landscape.

This is what country suitable and sustainable for cattle grazing looks like

IMG_2059.jpg

Or This
IMG_2067.jpg

Or even this

IMG_2382 (1).jpg

This is sustainable because cattle actually thrive on GRASS!

This land below is not compatible with cattle grazing. Grass is almost entirely absent and the plants available are so thin as to take up to 80 acres to sustain a single animal.

spring camping 2011 - 099.jpg

Scrubland consists mostly of mostly scattered woody plants, cactus and increasingly, invasive species. It is only sustainable with huge below market grazing subsidies and out sourced supplemental feeding. Just like other industries reliant on government largesse and huge direct agricultural payments it should be allowed to expire. The costs of producing cattle and the additional external costs ( erosion, degradation of resource, invasion of non native species, huge transportation and energy costs, imported labor and immigration costs ) make for an extremely inefficient market in Utah. Welfare ranching creates entitlement and market failures that are harmful both to the ranchers and the land.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
desertvic The Grand Staircase Escalante NM needs you! Meet Up (Members Only) 1
fossana Public comment for revised Grand Staircase Escalante NM management plan (comments open 11 Aug - 9 Nov) General Discussion 11
gnwatts Grand Staircase General Discussion 4
I Water in Frisky Creek south of Highway 12 in the Grand Staircase? Trip Planning 0
Wanderlust073 Skiing Grand Staircase Winter Sports 4
Stephanie B Grand Staircase Escalante National Monument - Kanab Area Hiking & Camping 2
Titans Permits car camping Grand Staircase Escalante NM? Trip Planning 6
Artemus PUBLIC COMMENT - Bears Ears and Grand Staircase Escalante Management Plans General Discussion 19
slc_dan Silent Auction for Grand Staircase Partners General Discussion 0
J The Grand Staircase-Escalante NM. Paria-Hackberry 10 day backpack April 23-May 2, 2017 Part 3 Backpacking 4
J In Grand Staircase (GSENM), Paria-Hackberry 10 Days backpacking April 23-May 2, 2017 Part 1 Backpacking 0
George_Washington_Hayduke Grand Staircase Escalante National Monument: Little Death Hollow/Horse/Wolverine Loop Backpacking 0
Henk Massive Flash Flood, Grand Staircase Utah August 4th 2016 General Discussion 3
BJett Random Wanderings - Grand Staircase-Escalante national Monument Hiking & Camping 7
N Trip Recommendations- Grand Staircase Escalante Area 7 days Trip Planning 11
Phill Monson Rained out in Grand Staircase Photography 13
IntrepidXJ The Vermilion Cliffs to The Grand Staircase Hiking & Camping 6
Nick Grand Staircase Escalante Road Conditions, Sept 2012 General Discussion 2
Dave Capitol Reef, Grand Staircase-Escalante, Bryce Canyon (March 24-27, 2011) Hiking & Camping 15
Nick Cottonwood Canyon, Grand Staircase Hiking & Camping 6
Nick Sand Creek, Grand Staircase-Escalante Backpacking 7
NateGeesaman Grand Staircase Escalante National Monument March 2012 Hiking & Camping 19
Nick Willis Creek, Grand Staircase-Escalante Hiking & Camping 2
w9jim Invite Grand Staircase-Escalante in September Meet Up (Members Only) 3
TractorDoc Paintbrush Canyon / Cascade Canyon Loop -- Grand Teton NP September 11, 2023 Hiking & Camping 9
D Grand Teton Cascade Loop Trip Planning 1
TheMountainRabbit Request: Grand Teton Ascent Trip Planning 0
Janice Such a GRAND Canyon - Deer Creek / Tapeats / Thunder River Backpacking 21
M Mee/Knowles Canyon Loop, Grand Junction Colorado Backpacking 4
OldBill Short hike at the Grand Canyon of Pennsylvania Hiking & Camping 1
TheMountainRabbit Ortenburger Lake, Talus Lake, & Glacier Peak (Grand Teton NP) - October 2023 Backpacking 14
TheMountainRabbit Invite Grand Teton NP, October 7th-10th 2023 Meet Up (Members Only) 0
Bob The New Grand Canyon Trip Planning 1
F Grand Canyon hermits rest to granite rapids to bright angel Trip Planning 10
RyanP Grand Gulch last-minute questions Trip Planning 14
fiber Lower Grand Gulch Pour-off Trip Planning 9
NorthwestWanderer Backpacking Grand Teton National Park : Fossil Pass,Fox Creek Pass,Indian Lake,Alaska Basin,Hurricane Pass,Ice Floe Lake,& Snowdrift Lake Backpacking 19
C Grand Gulch Cedar Mesa Utah 11 Day Backpack October 2022 Backpacking 10
dennisrodman A week in the Grand Canyon / Boucher / Hermit / Tonto Trail Trip Planning 4
futurafree Grand Canyon norovirus General Discussion 6
PaulMags Grand - Moab Route Backpacking 1
TrailScot Dripping Canyon to Grand Gulch, Cedar Mesa, Utah - March 2022 Hiking & Camping 7
Kerrie at Thru We Go Grand Canyon Backpack/Packraft Loop at New Hance Backpacking 11
H Access to Grand Gulch via Water Canyon Trip Planning 2
M Kannah Creek Basin loop, Grand Junction CO Backpacking 6
M Grand Canyon NP, Royal Arch Route Backpacking 0
D Springs in Grand Gulch 2022 Trip Planning 21
Janice Family trip to Grand Teton Memorial Day weekend? Trip Planning 5
westy Grand Canyon-Parashant NM, Parashant canyon Hiking & Camping 4
marquis20 Day 1: Grand Teton Wilderness and Black Canyon of the Yellowstone - June 2021 Backpacking 0

Similar threads

Back
Top