Going tent-free with bears?

Nick

-
.
Joined
Aug 9, 2007
Messages
12,918
I'm heading out on a 5-day, 84-mile river trip through Desolation and Grey Canyons on the Green River next week. There have been numerous reports of bear issues out there this year, some of which have resulted in bears being killed or relocated. One first-hand report I read stated that one curious bear was caught looking into a tent at night. Oh, and another person actually had a bear bite them on the head. Not the same head bite that happened in Colorado, this one happened almost the same time.

With that all said, I really hate sleeping in a tent. I much prefer just sleeping on the ground with nothing around me. But this has me thinking a bit. Does that stupid nylon and mesh contraption actually do me any good if Yogi comes sniffing around one night? Or is it purely mental? I don't love the idea of getting bit on the head, or waking up to bear breath, but I also don't love the idea of a hot, muggy tent every night.

And if any of you have done Deso, is there enough of a problem with mice that I'll want the tent anyway? The campsites on the Yampa in June were pretty much mousapalooza so I ended up tenting a few nights for that reason alone. They don't usually wake me up but there's something about getting out of bed and looking down to see an imprint of your body surrounded by mouse prints that isn't so great.
 

Rockskipper

No ETA
.
Joined
Jun 11, 2017
Messages
2,939
Never done Deso-Gray, but I'm thinking of getting a hammock and foregoing tent camping in the future. Not sure if there would be enough places along the Green there to hang one (probably would be), but you would be higher up off the ground and could be face-to-face with a bear if one messed with you, easy for bear-spray shooting. Get a bug net as well as a tarp cover and you're all set. No worries about mice, scorpions, kangaroo rats, snakes, or rabid frogs. Bears can smell you, whether in a tent or not, though I sometimes wonder if they just think the tent is a special kind of wrapper and this makes them even more curious and likely to mess around to see what it is.
 
Last edited:

Nick

-
.
Joined
Aug 9, 2007
Messages
12,918
I'm a side/stomach sleeper so hammock camping has no appeal to me, although I do enjoy relaxing in one. I just couldn't stay in one all night. Most of my tents are mostly mesh so a bug net+tarp is basically just a tent to me, especially since weight is of no issue on the river.
 

Rockskipper

No ETA
.
Joined
Jun 11, 2017
Messages
2,939
Well, I originally read that as moose prints instead of mouse prints. :)

Would something like OR's bug bivvy keep the mice off yet let you feel like you were outside? I don't think a bear would care much whether you were in a tent or not if it wanted to bother you. Here in W. Colorado we're also having lots of bear problems. Not enough food in the high country this year.
 

Outdoor_Fool

Member
.
Joined
Dec 11, 2015
Messages
1,724
Some research has shown that a tent slightly decreases your chance of a negative bear encounter, as Herrero puts it, a tent provides a "psychological barrier" for bears. Interpret that as you wish. As for me, if the bug situation allows it, I sleep under the stars.
 

SKLund

Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2016
Messages
459
You may want to get an air horn (there are a bunch on Amazon). Don't know about bear spray in this situ. Self harm may be likely. Of course having your food ungettable is always a good idea. If you use an Ursack and oder liner may be in order. Hard side container better still.
 

WasatchWill

Ready For More
.
Joined
Jul 23, 2013
Messages
1,540
Tough call...unless weather dictates otherwise, I usually prefer a mesh tent with no fly or a fly pinned back for maximum ventilation. Psychologically speaking, I like to be able to shine a flashlight out and see what's making noises around me and be able to prepare myself for a bear encounter should I find one sniffing around my camp (assuming I hear it before it's close enough to breathe on me), whereas, with a fly surrounding me, I'm left guessing what critters are out making all the noises around my camp, and it's not so fun when my imagination starts running wild with "what if" thoughts in those situations.
 

Rockskipper

No ETA
.
Joined
Jun 11, 2017
Messages
2,939
OK, ask the expert, Stephen Herrero, and according to the link I found, he says:

I have mentioned that another technique for minimizing risk while backcountry camping around bears is to sleep in a tent rather than without shelter. Sleeping under the stars is one of my favorite things to do while camping, but I choose areas in which to do this carefully. My data strongly suggest that people sleeping without tents were more likely to be injured, even killed, than were people who slept in tents.

https://outdoors.stackexchange.com/...rovide-some-protection-from-bears/11740#11740
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
IntrepidXJ Canyonlands Permits going to Recreation.gov General Discussion 4
zionsky Going to Jail General Discussion 3
LarryBoy Going South this Weekend? Meet Up (Members Only) 4
Brad Going places Noobs: Introduce yourself! 4
P Question about going around Shoshone Lake in Yellowstone Trip Planning 0
D South Coyote Buttes. We are going to put in at Lone Tree Reservoir because we don't have 4wd but we want to make it to White Pocket. Trip Planning 30
Vegan.Hiker Going cold (and cold soaking) Gear 40
Rockskipper Going canyoneering? Don't forget the dish soap. General Discussion 0
DrNed Going Tentless Gear 12
Nanda Anyone going out this weekend? Trip Planning 12
WasatchWill Going Solo in Capitol Reef Backpacking 27
mak1277 Who's going out this weekend? General Discussion 10
Laura Is it worth going into the Narrows in August? Trip Planning 25
pixie1339 Invite Anyone going to Capitol Reef this weekend? Meet Up (Members Only) 4
Shaverkid Going Camping - Suggestions Trip Planning 4
Nick Anyone going to The Winds over Labor Day? General Discussion 5
pixie1339 Anyone going to Ryder or Kermsuh this weekend? Trip Planning 2
Archbishop Going on a short bike tour next weekend. Trip Planning 9
norwegianxplorer Backpacking Norway in the fog, trying out my new 4 season tent Trip Reports 3
Perry Free Duo Free-standing Tent from Zpacks Gear 8
westy Stuff to let go - pack, tent, jacket Gear Market: Buy, Sell, Trade 0
Perry Drop/Dan Durston XMID Two Person Tent Coming Gear 0
D Trekking poles for lightweight tent Gear 15
Perry Interesting New One Person Tent - Review Video Added Gear 34
Miya Yay! Another Tent and Trail Runners! Gear 8
B Upgrading Big Agnes tent question Gear 10
JackBurns Backpacking tent Gear 6
Miya New tent! New tent! Gear 14
DrNed First Look at Ultralight Tent Gear 23
Uncle_Dim Lightheart Gear Duo 2 Person Tent For Sale Gear 2
N Tent specs Gear 34
H Recommended me a 4 person tent on a budget Gear 13
Perry Sierra Designs High Route 1FL Tent - Looks interesting Gear 6
Tystevens New tent suggestions Gear 12
D light tent, 1P, alps, cheap Gear 3
N Do I need a tent General Discussion 7
Mike Jones Bivy or One Man Tent Gear 25
Dirkules Multi-day hike: questions on tent/food? Gear 19
Outdoors24 Tent help Gear 10
Dustin Gent Big Agnes Shield 2 tent - 1st impression Gear 15
Vegan.Hiker Gear Review Terra Nova Solar Photon 2 Tent Review Gear Reviews 9
Nick Tent Seam Sealing Gear 5
Laura How to take glowing tent campsite photos Photography 35
katuah Big Agnes demo tent sale Gear 9
ogg Carbon Fiber Tent Poles Gear 4
natylka Advice on the best light backpacking tent Gear 39
Laura My tent shot is the featured photo for Best of May 2014 Photography 8
Flaminghog2099 Hammock vs. tent camping Gear 24
steve Gear Review REI Quarter Dome T3 tent Gear Reviews 5
andyjaggy Tent footprints Gear 27

Similar threads

Don't like ads? Become a BCP Supporting Member and kiss them all goodbye. Click here for more info.

Top