Danger signs in the wilderness??

Rockskipper

No ETA
.
Joined
Jun 11, 2017
Messages
3,371
This was discussed somewhat in the thread called the Mystery of Kim and Carol, but in a way it's a topic on its own, so will start a new thread. We've had a lot of deaths here in the West Elks of Colorado so far this year (7), especially Capitol Peak (4 to date), and SAR has performed lots of rescues, one which they said was probably the riskiest they've done in 30 years.

So, now people are pressuring the Feds to put up signage in the wilderness. IMO, it's just more of the social media thing where people become aware of a cool place and have to go get a selfie. There have always been deaths in the backcountry, but the number of visitors is becoming a danger in itself. Hanging Lake just enacted a shuttle/permit system because of the overuse. It feels like solitude is getting harder to come by.

http://www.postindependent.com/news...e-backcountry-travelers-to-prepare-for-risks/
 

Outdoor_Fool

Member
.
Joined
Dec 11, 2015
Messages
1,853
While I can understand the Sheriff's frustration, a sign at the trailhead should suffice. Beyond that, the visitors must understand that they are responsible for their own decisions.

I envision the day that there are signs scattered along all trails listing hazards but somehow, one hazard is not mentioned and that particular hazard kills someone. Then the FS is sued for insufficient warnings. Bring on the nanny state.
 

regehr

Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2012
Messages
1,564
I definitely appreciate the various signs one sometimes sees at the trailhead warning of rattlesnakes or bears or whatever. If I came from out of state or out of the USA I might not know about these things or have any easy way to guess their existence in some particular area. But in general the kind of people who are taking the biggest risks are unlikely to read or pay attention to the signs, right? Anyway you do see some super dumb stuff particularly in the frontcountry but most people survive it.
 

Jackson

I like to go outside.
.
Joined
May 31, 2015
Messages
2,689
I can understand warnings at the trailhead, but anything beyond that is excessive. Warning people at the trailhead that a trail has some exposure could be good, but I'd imagine nearly all people heading off to summit a high, rocky peak are already aware of that.
 

Dave

Broadcaster, formerly "ashergrey"
.
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
1,722
Assumption of risk. Big no from me on any signage in designated wilderness. I'm a little more flexible in heavily used backcountry but would still lean to no.
 

regehr

Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2012
Messages
1,564
Here is a wonderful sign. I think the fact that Angel's Landing is still open means that we're not hellbound for a nanny state just yet.

z10.jpg
 

Shirt357

Member
.
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
251
Honestly I think that you could put up 5 million signs, warnings, etc. and have briefings, hand out pamphlets, etc. and you would still have these issues. From what I have seen, there are just those people who do not "get it" and just act like these places are another scenic tourist attraction like Disney or something. It may be one reason I try to go to less known or traveled locations because some of the things I have seen make me really wonder about people. Everything from flip flops, no water, no rain gear, etc.

It is definitely the responsibility of the person taking on the hike/backpack trip, or climb however every time the rescuers have to go out they risk their own lives and use up valuable resources that limit them in other areas. I honestly am not sure what the solution is... but it is not more signs or other tactics people will/can just ignore.
 

IntrepidXJ

ADVENTR
Joined
Jan 17, 2012
Messages
3,414

SteveR

Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2016
Messages
542
Generally I am against signs, and for personal responsibility, but:
In the Canadian Rockies close to Calgary, our local Kananaskis safety team rescued a total 19 hikers last week! Eleven separate callouts on one recent weekend! And that does not include Banff NP. Typically these consist of a mix of user groups as this is a multi-use zone- hikers, climbers, boaters, ATV'er's and MTB'er's. Last week though, it was mostly hikers, on several popular peaks that feature well beaten ascent routes and cellphone reception. The three common factors were late starts, footwear suited for the shopping mall or tennis court, and lack of preparedness (no headlamps or warm clothing). At least the rescuers weren't risking their own lives as they all too often do- by being slung under a heli in marginal flying conditions to save cliffed out hikers or scramblers, as they were able to hike up at 0 dark hundred in 3 instances to get these unprepared fools to safety.
Maybe it is time for some explicit signage at trailheads for popular Banff and Kananaskis summits, many of which have a long history of people getting into trouble.
Something like this?
20130615_IMG_1869-copy-2.jpg
 
Last edited:

Ben

Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2014
Messages
1,873
reminds me of the signs along the Mist Trail in Yosemite telling of the people that have died getting swept over the waterfalls. doesn't seem out of place there, so many people that trail is a mall.
 

Wanderlust073

Member
.
Joined
Oct 30, 2016
Messages
848
Just scanned past some article related to the girl who died climbing to Conundrum hot springs or wherever, making a big deal that everyone needs to be aware that if you start feeling sick at elevation the cure is to get lower.

I realize that no one is born with such knowledge, but if you're heading up a mountain without having done the minimal amount of research required to uncover that basic fact beforehand, it seems unlikely that you're the type to notice, read or take the warnings of a trailhead sign to heart.

Some times the herd thins itself...
 

Wanderlust073

Member
.
Joined
Oct 30, 2016
Messages
848
But if you watch this video, you'll see why it still doesn't really matter. Mountain bikers are nuts. :confused:

I love how he taps the sign as he goes by, lol
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
MVS Animal Danger General Discussion 42
Parma Let's See Your US National Parks Signs Photos Photography 19
IntrepidXJ Album Signs Photography 121
HomerJ 19 Signs You’re Addicted to Gear General Discussion 7
Mikjik86 4 Days Backpacking Grand Teton Wilderness/Teton Crest Trail - Wyoming, July, 2021 Backpacking 0
balzaccom Yosemite...wilderness permits for 2022 are better Backpacking 2
F Balancing Urban Life with wilderness Solitude Noobs: Introduce yourself! 1
TeamJenkins17 Looking for info on Clark Creek drainage/Pierpont Pass into Hidden Basin in the Washakie Wilderness Trip Planning 5
TeamJenkins17 2022 Teton Wilderness/Shoshone National Forest Trip Trip Planning 0
TheMountainRabbit Southern Absaroka Loop (Teton Wilderness) - August 2021 Backpacking 8
NorthwestWanderer Backpacking Idaho's Cecil D. Andrus-White Clouds Wilderness : O'Calkens Lake & Bighorn Basin Backpacking 2
la_alpinista Thoughts on potential off trail routes in Cloud Peak Wilderness CPW Trip Planning 0
scatman Beartooth Wilderness - Flat Rock Lake Lollipop Loop - July 26, 2021 Backpacking 56
AKay09 Rawah Wilderness Fire Question Trip Planning 3
D Backpacking Advice in the Winds, Teton Wilderness and the Washakie Wilderness Trip Planning 8
TheMountainRabbit Gros Ventre Wilderness - June 2021 Backpacking 10
JuddOutdoors Hike To Grass Lake //Desolation Wilderness //Lake Tahoe Basin Hiking & Camping 0
Dreamer Bisti/De-Na-Zin Wilderness 4/19-21/21 Backpacking 14
TheMountainRabbit Bowen-Baker Loop (Never Summer Wilderness) - June 2020 Backpacking 1
TheMountainRabbit Invite Gros Ventre Wilderness, June 11th-13th Meet Up (Members Only) 5
BJett Joyce Kilmer-Slickrock Wilderness Area. North Carolina. Backpacking 0
J Moving down to Southern San Rafael Reef Wilderness for two more loop hikes April 13-14 2021 Hiking & Camping 1
J San Rafael Reef Wilderness. Rambling on the Reef March 30-31, 2021 Hiking & Camping 1
IlVagabondo Encampment River Wilderness: Conditions? Trip Planning 0
M Bob Marshall Wilderness Trip Planning 0
M Overnight Backpacking Indian Peaks Wilderness or Similar Trip Planning 13
Dreamer Alice - Toxaway Loop | Sawtooth Wilderness Backpacking 6
TeamJenkins17 Fox Park-Teton Wilderness Trip Backpacking 6
Tim Valentine Hoover Wilderness August 2020 Backpacking 9
Mountain Wanderer A smoky trip into the Bob Marshall Wilderness Backpacking 2
BJett Dolly Sods Wilderness - West Virginia Backpacking 17
Yvonne Zion Wilderness Permits and Canyoneering permits opened up again General Discussion 11
S Conejos - South San Juan Wilderness Backpacking 2
C High Uintas Wilderness - Last minute plans Trip Planning 4
NorthwestWanderer 6 Day Eagle Cap Wilderness Odyssey | Cross Country Travel | The Highlight Highway Loop Backpacking 6
Mountain Wanderer Cedar Lakes Loop in Montana's Cabinet Mountains Wilderness Backpacking 4
balzaccom Ansel Adams Wilderness--smoke and mirrors Backpacking 8
ergelo Trail conditions in Arc Dome Wilderness (NV) Trip Planning 2
McKee80 Roaring Plains West Wilderness Backpacking 8
Titans Pharaoh Lake Wilderness- some much needed Vitamin W Hiking & Camping 5
Mountain Wanderer High Uintas Wilderness - Granddaddy Basin Backpacking 4
Curt Visiting (Part of) the Lake District of Cloud Peak Wilderness Backpacking 15
Miya 2nd Solo - Trinity Alps Wilderness - Wildflower Madness! Backpacking 50
D Recommendations in the Gros Ventre and Washakie Wilderness Areas Trip Planning 10
NorthwestWanderer Overnight Backpack to Louis Lake, Lake Chelan-Sawtooth Wilderness Backpacking 4
kwc Wiliam C. Whitney Wilderness canoe camping (Adirondacks) On The Water 10
J Grenadier Range, San Juan Mtns. Weminuche Wilderness, CO June 27-30, 2007 Retro Backpacking 9
westy Fishhawk Creek, Washakie Wilderness Area Trip Planning 4
J Mount Nutt Wilderness Cave Spring Area dayhike Nov 26, 2019 Hiking & Camping 0
UtahBrian Sids Mountain Wilderness November 2019 Backpacking 5

Similar threads

Don't like ads? Become a BCP Supporting Member and kiss them all goodbye. Click here for more info.

Top