Hikers Rescued from Subway

Is it typical for people to attempt this hike in the middle of winter? I would have thought it would be avoided due to the hypothermia risk, and this almost ended like the recent Narrows death that was posted here 2 months ago. Is the need for rescues increasing over time? I've only heard about these kinds of rescues since I started using BCP a few years ago, so I don't have a sense of whether this is typical or if things have changed in recent years. For those of you who've paid attention for awhile, I'm curious - are more people making unsafe choices these days?
 
Last edited:
Stupid
 
For many people common sense died long ago and any form of sense they have left is on life support.............I feel bad for SAR groups as there is now a non-stop flow of Idiots in the backcountry who are in need of rescues due to zero planning and taking all the wrong supplies.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bob
Were they issued a permit or did they just go without one?
 
Is it typical for people to attempt this hike in the middle of winter? I would have thought it would be avoided due to the hypothermia risk, and this almost ended like the recent Narrows death that was posted here 2 months ago. Is the need for rescues increasing over time? I've only heard about these kinds of rescues since I started using BCP a few years ago, so I don't have a sense of whether this is typical or if things have changed in recent years. For those of you who've paid attention for awhile, I'm curious - are more people making unsafe choices these days?
It all depends on the snow. The exit point is at a lower elevation so it may be possible to do a bottoms up route. But given all the snow at the higher elevation this winter, I would imagine just getting to the wildcat TH would be difficult, let alone following the top down route. No way I'd try those steep slopes and drop offs with snow and ice.
 
I like the way in the very first line of the article they make sure it's clear to everyone that it's "two-out-of-state hikers" from NY and NV. Ha! Small-town St. George paper simultaneously letting you know a) it's not one of your friends and b) it's exactly what you were expecting.
 
I would be very surprised if rangers issued a permit this time of year.
That was also my initial reaction. But if they had entered the Left Fork without a permit, I would've expected the NPS to underscore this in its press release in order to deter others from trying the same thing.
 
I would be very surprised if rangers issued a permit this time of year.
You can get a permit this time of the year. But you need to be well-prepared and know what you're doing. There are usually a few feet of snow to begin with at Wildcat TH, so you often have to break trail first to even get to the access point to go to the Subway.
And scrambling down that lava cliff in snow and ice if you intend to do the bottom-up route is no joke.
I did it once bottom-up end of December; it was no joke.
And I also snowshoed a few times from Wildcat to the permit-only area so I could update Wilderness about the conditions. And each time, there were at least 2-3 feet of snow.
 
I'm a little surprised to hear they would issue top down permits. I could see the bottoms up maybe. From the video, you can clearly see a lot of snow on the ground. Several of the rap anchors are kind of slippery to get to even in good weather. They made it 2/3 of the way down the route so I'm wondering what stopped them. Possibly injury or not being able to find an anchor covered in snow??
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
ScienceMom Hello from Vegas! And anyone have advice for helping reluctant-hikers enjoy backpacking more? Noobs: Introduce yourself! 25
Brendan S Powell shuttle for hikers? Trip Planning 6
R Survival Stories from Utah hikers General Discussion 0
isleroyaleguy This just in: Hikers are cool! General Discussion 3
Nurrgle Hikers behaving badly: Appalachian Trail partying raises ire General Discussion 13
crazydoghiker Hey Hikers, new gal here from SLC area Noobs: Introduce yourself! 6
klank Self-Declared 'Rubber Tramp' Shuttles PCT Through-Hikers General Discussion 0
ROKTAXI 5 hikers killed.... Colorado General Discussion 2
wnorton Red Rock Hikers (Southern Utah and Nevada) General Discussion 0
Rockskipper Zion National Park visitors rescued after mocking rangers, hiking The Subway unprepared General Discussion 97
Perry Injured Utah Hiker Rescued Near Kings Peak General Discussion 9
regehr hiker injured and rescued in Little Cottonwood General Discussion 3
Nick Dog abandoned at 14,000 feet, rescued 9 days later General Discussion 23
Yvonne The Subway September 2020 - a trip that went wrong Hiking & Camping 10
Yvonne Subway Bottom Up July 8, 2019 Hiking & Camping 27
RyanP How to prepare for Subway/Orderville/etc Trip Planning 6
Red Rock Rangers The Subway Canyoneering 0
Nick The other Subway in Zion General Discussion 17
jentzschman Subway trip mid June Trip Planning 5
Howells Outdoors Frigid in The Subway Canyoneering 6
IntrepidXJ The Subway and Left Fork Hiking & Camping 2
Scott Chandler The Subway 10-28-14 Canyoneering 9
Sandro The Subway - End of April Trip Planning 13
Tyler The Subway August 2012 Canyoneering 1
Nick Russell Gulch & The Subway Canyoneering 13
gloo The Subway - Zion NP August 2012 Canyoneering 2
Dave Fatality in Zion's Subway General Discussion 24
Ross Invite Pine Creek, Misery Canyon or The Subway (Zion area) Meet Up (Members Only) 1
Nick Changes in The Subway General Discussion 1
blueeyes Subway August 2, 2012 Hiking & Camping 1
blueeyes Subway May 20th Hiking & Camping 4
Tyler The Subway was off the hook! General Discussion 9
A Subway any way I can - don't laugh! Trip Planning 9
lostlandscapes The Subway -- June 23, 2012 Canyoneering 9
lostlandscapes Best time to hike The Subway General Discussion 2
Nick The Subway, May 2012 Canyoneering 37
Nick Zion Subway Conditions Spring 2012 General Discussion 2
Nick The Subway, Zion National Park Canyoneering 11
Nick The Subway and Russell Gulch Canyoneering 5
Nick The Zion Subway, August 2011 Canyoneering 6
Ndheiner The Subway in Zion Trip Planning 8

Similar threads

Back
Top