Searching for Melvin Heaps

Discussion in 'Hiking & Camping' started by Dave, Nov 6, 2017.

  1. Dave

    Dave Broadcaster, formerly "ashergrey"

    Messages:
    1,563
    Location:
    SL,UT
    Melvin Heaps went for a hike off the Crystal Lake Trailhead on July 31, 2017. He didn't come home that night and his family reported him missing.

    A full-scale search effort launched late that night. Over the course of the next week, deputies, search dogs, volunteers and helicopter crews scoured the area around Trial/Washington/Wall Lakes without success.

    This area seems to be the Bermuda Triangle of Utah's mountains. People vanish in the general vicinity of the Mirror Lake Highway with some frequency.

    I was away on a family vacation when Melvin went for his walk in the woods. I only learned of it while coming back into cell service at the opposite end of the range, near Manila, on Tuesday afternoon. I wanted to help in the search, but my car had broken down along I-80 in Echo Canyon and I had some family obligations that required attention.

    Still, I made some effort to try and contribute, even after the official search was scaled back at the end of that week.

    The Summit County Sheriff's Office tweeted a screen shot showing their GPS tracks. I contacted their PIO, who graciously provided the data file to me.

    Screen Shot 2017-11-06 at 12.14.14 AM.png

    Red tracks are hikers/horses while the purple are dogs. Here's a closer look at the trailhead.

    Screen Shot 2017-11-06 at 12.15.07 AM.png

    There are a couple of take-aways for me when looking at the search tracks. First, is Melvin is not on a trail. Protocol for this type of search would be to send teams out along all of the trails ASAP. They clearly did so.

    Second, the likelihood of Melvin being near the trailhead are low. The area was covered extensively and in a short amount of time after his initial disappearance.

    My approach then, in planning reconnaissance hikes, was to look for gaps in the search grid. Where possible, I would avoid the established trails. Any time spent on the trail was wasted, I reasoned, as we know with certainty Melvin is not on one.

    This trip report is three in one, covering three outings in search of Melvin Heaps (green are my tracks).

    Screen Shot 2017-11-06 at 12.18.16 AM.png

    August 12, 2017

    Search area 1.jpg

    My first outing focused on the area at the center of this image. The half-circle of small ponds along the 10,200 contour line, north of Star Lake.

    Screen Shot 2017-11-06 at 12.17.17 AM.png

    It is heavily wooded, tucked between two very active legs of the Notch Mountain Trail but not directly accessed by any trail of its own.

    To reach it, I passed by Teapot, Diamond and Star Lakes.

    _MG_9666.jpg

    The slopes around the half-moon bench were choked with deadfall. The ponds though were surrounded by meadow.

    _MG_9671.jpg

    From there, I worked my way up to the slopes of Notch Mountain for a birds-eye view.

    _MG_9679.jpg

    _MG_9685.jpg

    It never ceases to amaze me how well sound travels in the clear mountain air. I could almost make out the conversations of these noisy hikers down at Wall Lake.

    _MG_0024.jpg

    Traversing westward along the slope of Notch Mountain, I kept an eye out for anything that looked out of place below. Mount Watson is near center, Wall Lake at the left and the Notch at far right. It's a good bet Melvin is somewhere visible in this image.

    _MG_9691.jpg

    Looking west across the Notch.

    _MG_0036.jpg

    I arrived at the Notch via an improvised scramble route to find a shirtless guy and a gal in a sports bra loudly discussing religion and politics. Couldn't get away from them quickly enough.

    _MG_9696.jpg

    The Notch is a prominent destination for hikers and enough of a climb that a 74-year-old like Melvin may very well have sought but struggled to reach it. This area was not searched very thoroughly.

    Rather than heading straight down the trail to Ibantik Lake, I made a slight detour to the north to go past a series of ponds near Lake Lovenia.

    A lot of people camp at Ibantik and I reasoned it wouldn't make much sense to stick close to the lake for that reason. I cut across the head and pushed up into the hills east of it.

    _MG_9713.jpg

    _MG_9725.jpg

    From above Ibantik, I could clearly see Meadow Lake and off down the Main Fork Weber River drainage.

    _MG_0046.jpg

    And looking across the Weber River basin offered views into Cuberant Basin. I've stood atop these cliffs and peered back the opposite direction on other hikes.

    _MG_0062.jpg

    The sight of bones at a distance gave me pause, but it turned out to be a deer. The carcass had obviously been well predated but the amount of fur and intact nature of the skeleton made me think the death must have been relatively recent.

    _MG_9729.jpg

    I rounded the northern tip of Notch Mountain and dropped down to the trail.

    _MG_9745.jpg

    Daylight was running short and I was feeling a bit tired. Not only that, but weather was gathering on the horizon.

    _MG_9750.jpg

    _MG_0065.jpg

    The winter of 16-17 was such a boon to the Uintas. Normally by so late in the summer, the lakes are drawn down and creeks are just trickling. Not so during the summer of 2017. Notch Lake was still high and dumping a good amount of water.

    _MG_9772.jpg

    It became obvious I was not going to make the car by nightfall so I increased the pace. Then the fading daylight hit Reid and Bald Mountains. I had to stop at Dean Lake and capture it.

    _MG_9821.jpg

    _MG_9829.jpg

    _MG_9905.jpg

    _MG_9893.jpg

    The photographic diversion cost me. I should have stayed with the trail but instead made the dumb decision to continue the search in the dark, off trail.

    As such, I didn't make it back to the highway until quite late. I had told my parents I was only going out for the day and feared they would call out SAR if I didn't report in before midnight. I raced down to Kamas and checked in, then puked on the way home from a bit of exhaustion and altitude sickness.

    October 7, 2017

    Any search for a missing person in the area of the Crystal Lake TH is hampered if the searchers don't have a clear indication as to which trail the target of the search used.

    The Clyde Lake Loop and the Notch are obvious targets for hikers, but so are Long Lake or Island Lake. It is impossible to effectively search both of those areas in a reasonable amount of time.

    For my second hike, I started from the assumption someone might accidentally veer off the Clyde Lake trail and end up somewhere below Mount Watson's south face. From there, I cut across the head of the Middle Fork Weber River drainage in order to scan Ramona, Island, Fire and Duck Lakes.

    Search area 3.jpg

    As you can see, the official search completely omitted Ramona and Fire Lakes.

    Screen Shot 2017-11-06 at 12.18.54 AM.png

    The hike started with an easy trail jaunt up to Watson Lake, passing by well-searched areas like Cliff Lake.

    IMG_9957.jpg

    At the head of Lake Watson I left the trail and started working up along a rocky slope to the foot of Mount Watson.

    IMG_9959.jpg

    Notch, Reid and Bald Mountains from the lower slopes of Mount Watson.

    IMG_9960.jpg

    The Notch, as visible from near the same vantage point.

    _MG_0008 1.jpg

    Rounding the mountain, Timpanogos came into view down south.

    _MG_0012 1.jpg

    Wildlife signs were abundant. These coyote tracks were frozen in the snow. Cat scat was around as well but alas, no sighting of a cougar or bobcat.

    _MG_0014 1.jpg

    Rounding Watson, east Long Mountain came into view.

    IMG_9964.jpg

    A pass sits between east Long and Long Mountain proper. I'd thought I might cross it, but the northern approach looked a bit too snowy.

    _MG_0023.jpg

    Instead, I tried to stay to the 10,400 contour line while heading toward Ramona.

    IMG_9966.jpg

    The snow made it tough to know if I might be hiking past something important.

    IMG_9968.jpg

    IMG_9975.jpg

    Island Lake and its smaller satellites sit on a high bench. Looking off the edge gave a great view of the whole North Fork Provo River headwaters. That's Duck Lake down below.

    IMG_9970.jpg

    The dam at Fire Lake impressed me. So much effort went into constructing it and the structure has weathered well.

    IMG_9980.jpg

    From Fire, I picked a path down the cliff bands and to Duck Lake. A bald eagle swooped low over the water, angry at me for scaring away the rising fish.

    _MG_0047 1.jpg

    I was developing a raging headache at this point and decided to cut the search short. Rejoining the trail, I headed straight back to the trailhead and arrived just before sundown.

    November 4, 2017

    The forecast called for snow. A significant amount of it, probably enough to blanket the mountains with enough powder to bury any sign of Melvin until spring. It was the final shot of the season for me.

    The Bald Mountain Pass weather station told a discouraging story: ambient temperatures below freezing with winds gusting to 30 mph. It was not going to be a typical summer lark.

    Ambitious mileage would have to wait until warmer months. I aimed to check two spaces nearer to the trailhead. One, above Cliff Lake and the other between Wall and Clyde Lakes.

    Screen Shot 2017-11-06 at 12.16.35 AM.png

    Screen Shot 2017-11-06 at 12.15.51 AM.png

    Search area 2.jpg

    There were only a few cars at the Crystal Lake Trailhead, a far cry from August when I was unable to park anywhere close to it. So while the weather wasn't the best of hiking I must say the mountains were quiet and lovely.

    _MG_0983.jpg

    I started out on the trail toward Wall Lake but soon left it, climbing the hill to obtain the region between Wall and Cliff Lakes.

    _MG_0929.jpg

    Clouds were racing by overhead. The sun never broke through in full, but occasionally the overcast would thin enough to allow some light.

    I headed over to Wall Lake's inlet, which comes down from Clyde Lake.

    _MG_0936.jpg

    Between the two lakes are a series of cliff bands which sit one atop another. From this angle, it is obvious what a challenge the terrain presents for any kind of search. Each of those steps has to be scanned individually.

    _MG_0950.jpg

    _MG_0955.jpg

    The clouds kept obscuring landmarks.

    _MG_0938.jpg

    After ascending to near Clyde Lake, I headed west along the 10,400 contour line. Snow pelted me and the clouds made Mount Watson vanish.

    _MG_0959.jpg

    I pushed west from this point, following a line of cliffs before finding a break that allowed me down to the meadow above Cliff Lake.

    _MG_0965.jpg

    Wind was howling. My ears started to feel the sting and I worried about frostbite. Conceding defeat, I headed back to the car.

    Until 2018, then.
     
    Hoobie, Jon Carbaugh, Ugly and 19 others like this.
  2. Jen

    Jen Formerly colefeet

    Messages:
    104
    Location:
    South Lyon, MI
    Well researched and well done, Dave. I'm sure his family is grateful for your help.
     
  3. regehr

    regehr Member

    Messages:
    500
    Location:
    Salt Lake City
    This is awesome but the throwing up from exhaustion / altitude wigged me out a little, be safe!
     
  4. Dave

    Dave Broadcaster, formerly "ashergrey"

    Messages:
    1,563
    Location:
    SL,UT
    It happens. That day I did 13 miles after driving up from the valley. I usually try to spend a night around 8,000 feet before doing any serious hiking at elevation but didn’t that time. I included that detail even though it’s embarrassing because it illustrates a point about how easy it is to under estimate risk.
     
    Hoobie and Cuberant like this.
  5. DrNed

    DrNed The mountains are calling and I must go

    Messages:
    766
    Location:
    Utah
    Dave, another excellent read. Thank you for your insights.

    When I met Kevin Bardsley a few years ago he had a map that
    showed easiest to most difficult lines of travel that would lead
    a person out of the Cuberant Basin, as a means of trying to
    determine the most likely path that Garrett took.

    Do you know if such technology is used by SAR?

    Knowing that falls are a leading cause of death in the backcountry,
    does data exist to show the most likely areas where a fall
    could happen?

    I can only imagine that his death and disappearance is
    likely similar to Eric Robinson's, meaning he fell in an
    unexpected area and the geography has made it difficult
    to identify unless you're in the right spot.

    Thanks again.
     
    Cuberant likes this.
  6. Cuberant

    Cuberant Member

    Messages:
    722
    Location:
    Morgan, UT
    Thanks for the great report @Dave. It has me reflecting on the day I spent helping with the volunteer SAR effort.

    I remember how, while searching areas off trail, I became overwhelmed at the hundreds of spots one could fall out of sight behind deadfall, among large rocks or into a stream bed obscured by tall grass. Some of the terrain we covered that day was rugged but fairly open to view while in other areas you could miss a hidden spot mere feet away. Once a missing individual goes horizontal in this kind of terrain is extremely easy to miss them.

    Sure wish we had had more info to go on to have *some* idea where he had gone that day.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
  7. Pringles

    Pringles Member

    Messages:
    76
    This is as interesting as the report about the two lost ladies. Is this in the same area? I'm sorry, but I don't know much about hiking areas in Utah. The pictures are great, especially the ones near sunset. Thank you for sharing.
     
  8. Cuberant

    Cuberant Member

    Messages:
    722
    Location:
    Morgan, UT
    Yes the same general area.
     
  9. Tim Valentine

    Tim Valentine Member

    Messages:
    53
    Location:
    San Diego, California
    At least you had a healthy serving of one of the benefits of SAR....the incredible scenery and a specific reason to be out there. Thanks for the great report. Everyone should always crank up the awareness in the backcountry. We need to look out for each other . Good job.

    tv
     
Loading...